Apple's design claim rejected
By Kim Yoo-chul A Korean court gave a partial victory to Samsung in its patent dispute with Apple, Friday. The three-judge panel in the Seoul Central District Court ruled that the Korean firm didn’t infringe on Apple’s designs, the key part of the iPhone maker’s legal argument, while the American firm copied two of Samsung’s wireless patents. The court ordered Apple to pay Samsung 40 million won in damages. Samsung was ordered to pay Apple 25 million won, with the court recognizing Apple’s claim that its rival infringed on its ``bounce-back’’ touch-screen feature. The ruling calls for Apple to stop selling iPhone 3GS, iPhone 4, iPad 1 and iPad 2 in Korea, while Samsung must stop selling the Galaxy S, Galaxy S II and Galaxy Tabs. ``We believe Apple’s i-devices such as iPhone 3GS infringed on two of Samsung’s wireless patents,’’ said the presiding Judge Bae Jun-hyon. The court didn’t accept the claim by Apple that Samsung copied the iPhone design and failed to meet its commitment for FRAND principles. ``Samsung Electronics didn’t copy the iPhone,’’ said the cou