Scandals mar minister nominees, testing Lee Jae Myung’s reform agenda

Lee Jin-sook, nominee for deputy prime minister for social affairs and minister of education, answers questions from lawmakers during her confirmation hearing at the National Assembly's Education Committee in Yeouido, Seoul, Wednesday. Yonhap
Controversies surrounding Education Minister nominee Lee Jin-sook and Gender Equality Minister nominee Kang Sun-woo have deepened, stirring unease within the ruling party.
On Tuesday, progressive groups — including the Korean Teachers and Education Workers Union and prominent academics — demanded Lee's resignation, both in the lead-up to and during her confirmation hearing.
Lee is under growing scrutiny over allegations of academic plagiarism and legal violations related to her daughter’s education abroad. Critics accuse Lee of copying portions of her scholarly work from a student’s thesis, and take issue with revelations that her daughter left for the United States to study alone before completing nine years of schooling — a requirement in Korea unless formally exempted.
During the hearing before the National Assembly’s Education Committee, Lee apologized for the controversy. “I sincerely apologize for the allegations that do not meet public expectations,” she said. However, she denied allegations of thesis plagiarism and misappropriation of a student’s research.
“I have not done anything that would be considered unethical as a scholar,” she said, adding that most of the disputed research was based on state-funded projects for which she had served as principal investigator.
In response to the plagiarism allegations, Lee stated that her student had developed the research into a dissertation and, as they had conducted the same experiments, some of the tables and figures were bound to be similar. Responding to criticism from an academic watchdog regarding serious instances of plagiarism in her thesis, she said that earlier external reviews had found the similarity rate to be below 10 percent.
She further defended her academic record, stating that the disputed content had been disclosed transparently in academic journals and undergone multiple peer reviews.
“The research in question contributed to several government-funded projects and was publicly accessible,” she said.
Regarding her daughter's alleged illegal overseas education, Lee took responsibility. “It was a major mistake on my part," she said.
She explained that her child had expressed a strong desire to study in the United States and ended up enrolled in boarding schools. Lee estimated the total expenses at around 300 million won ($216,000).
Kang Sun-woo, nominee for Minister of Gender Equality and Family, answers questions during her confirmation hearing before the National Assembly’s Gender Equality and Family Committee in Yeouido, Seoul, Monday. Yonhap
Lee also denied allegations that she had pressured students into adding her name as co-author on papers or had taken credit for their work improperly. “All co-authorships followed academic guidelines and were based on mutual consent,” she said.
Responding to criticism from lawmakers that she failed to grasp how academia views duplicate publication, she said, “I may have fallen short in recognizing evolving academic standards, but I have acted in good faith throughout my career.”
Despite her testimony, criticism from within progressive circles continued.
The Korean Teachers and Education Workers' Union held a press conference outside the State Affairs Planning Committee in Seoul, urging the president to withdraw her nomination. A coalition of scholars who had previously investigated plagiarism allegations against former first lady Kim Keon Hee also stated that Lee’s case was more serious.
The presidential office has yet to take a firm position. A senior official said that public opinion would be considered after the hearing. Although internal concerns remain, the Democratic Party of Korea (DPK) leadership has said that Lee’s situation does not warrant her withdrawal.
Kang Yu-jung, spokesperson for the presidential office, said during a briefing Tuesday that in the case of Lee, “Since the confirmation hearing has not yet concluded, we will assess the nominee’s explanations and the appropriateness of those explanations once the hearing is complete.”
Regarding Kang Sun-woo, the spokesperson added that the office is “closely reviewing the explanations provided and evaluating their persuasiveness with care.”
Meanwhile, nominee Kang continues to face allegations of mistreating aides, making false statements and paying wages late. Groups such as the Network of Women Politics and the Korea Women’s Hotline have issued statements urging her to withdraw from the nomination.
Observers have pointed out that the allegations could undermine the president’s efforts to portray his cabinet as committed to fairness and social responsibility. The government’s response to calls for resignations is being watched closely and could influence public confidence during the early stages of Lee’s term.
While the presidential office and the DPK leadership argue that the controversies are not severe enough to cancel a nomination, concerns persist regarding the public's rising expectations for fairness and common sense in public appointments.
A senior ruling party official said that public sentiment should be monitored further in the days following Lee’s hearing. The administration is expected to review the big picture and decide whether to proceed with the appointment, accept a voluntary resignation or withdraw the nomination.