From parliament to command: Can minister without military background reform Korea’s armed forces?

Defense Minister nominee Ahn Gyu-back answers reporters' questions as he arrives at his confirmation preparation office at the Army Club in Yongsan District, Seoul, June 27. Yonhap
New defense chief expected to bring massive shake-up, fresh role of ministry
Both expectations and concerns have been raised since Ahn Gyu-back, a five-term lawmaker who has spent nearly two decades on the National Assembly’s Defense Committee, was nominated as Korea’s first defense minister in 64 years without an extensive military background.
Facing a parliamentary confirmation hearing later this month, his nomination has opened an unusually public debate over how far civilian control of the armed forces should extend.
While many military officers welcome the symbolic break with a long-standing precedent where former generals took the position, some question whether a minister without a career in uniform can earn the trust of the troops.
A senior official from the ministry evaluated the change positively, arguing that the shift was long overdue. “The Ministry of National Defense is a policy house, not a field command,” the official said.
He said that past ministers who had risen through the ranks had often “behaved like battlefield commanders,” even after trading their uniforms for suits. “A minister should steer strategy, not count bullets or aircraft parts.”
Ahn supporters point to his legislative track record.
Since entering parliament in 2008, he has chaired the Defense Committee, proposed bills on troop welfare and military ombudsman oversight and led last year’s parliamentary inquiry into the Dec. 3 martial law crisis, during which special operations troops were mobilized to enter the National Assembly to prevent lawmakers from voting to lift the martial rule. During the investigation, he stated, “Those who ordered the illegal deployment must face justice, while rank-and-file soldiers who were forced to follow the order deserve compensation.”
The minister-designate says that his first priority is to boost morale. “The real weapon gap is not hardware, but confidence,” he told reporters after the nomination. To this end, he has introduced legislation that enables service members to refuse orders that clearly violate the Constitution.
This idea was inspired by Germany’s postwar model of “citizens in uniform.” He also supports the appointment of an independent ombudsman to investigate abuse and protect military whistleblowers.
Some within the military see opportunity in the impending shake-up. Reassignments are expected at the Joint Chiefs of Staff and the Defense Security Command, particularly among officers involved in the martial law incident. According to one field-grade officer, the priority is “clear lines” — operations must remain with the Joint Chiefs of Staff, while the ministry “should finally act like a civilian department that plans for demographics, budgets and alliances rather than daily deployments.”
Ahn has also adopted a cautious approach to two of Korea’s most sensitive defense issues: inter-Korean military tensions and cost-sharing negotiations with Washington for U.S. troops stationed here.
Describing North Korea as “both our enemy and our compatriot,” he said the 2018 inter-Korean military accord — partially suspended under the previous Yoon Suk Yeol administration — should be reassessed from the ground up, urging a “multitrack, sophisticated approach.” Rather than rushing to restore the agreement, he called for flexibility based on evolving conditions.
Regarding U.S. demands for greater burden-sharing and expanded operational flexibility of American forces stationed in Korea, Ahn emphasized a national interest-first approach. “As the world’s 10th-largest economy and fifth-ranked military, Korea should act with greater initiative,” he said, signaling that Seoul would pursue more assertive diplomacy in upcoming alliance talks.