ed Debate on free welfare

Programs’ continuity must be a matter of how, not whether

This is no election time in Korea, but partisan brawls over some free welfare programs are getting out of hand.

Some provincial governors from the conservative Saenuri Party are refusing to allocate budgets for free school meals, which is a ``welfare brand” of the liberal opposition New Politics Alliance for Democracy, citing the lack of money.

In response, a couple of regional educational chiefs affiliated with the NPAD are not allotting outlays for free childcare and the preschool education program, one of President Park’s election pledges.

Voters might feel tempted to criticize both parties, which are throwing away the other side’s welfare policies to save their own. If anything, however, the ruling camp should be more to blame, as the provincial governments’ provision of free school meals started as a bipartisan agreement and has become a national consensus.

On the other hand, President Park, while campaigning, confirmed that free childcare should be the central government’s work. As she did with so many other issues, however, she ate her words on this one, too, passing financial burdens to regional educational offices.

Yet the NPAD is on shaky ground in criticizing Park because Rep. Moon Jae-in, the opposition candidate and Park’s rival, made the same pledge. Can the NPAD say for sure the same would have not happened had it won the election?

At issue here is the gap between the state’s duty and its financial ability.

Ruling party officials appear to be right in this regard to call for both central and local governments to ``reconsider a priority list of welfare programs.”

We beg to differ. The partisan bickering will likely take the nation back to the debate over the fundamental question of which is better between universal and selective welfare. We believe in the former, especially as far as such basic things as school meals and childcare are concerned.

It has long ceased to be news that Korea’s welfare spending, including that on children’s welfare, is the lowest among member nations of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. The nation’s tax burden, on the other hand, is below the OECD’s average. Can there be any doubts, then about the direction in which Korea should go? Children, rich or poor, have the right to have meals with basic decency, and without feeling small. Free childcare is also a must to boost the nation’s dismal birthrate and make the most of the female workforce.

Conservatives ask why the government should provide free meals or childcare for the well-to-do. But welfare should be equal, something all people receive but pay for it differently, not the other way around. A chaebol owner’s child can, and should, have the same free meal as long as the rich father pays for it far more than others in taxes. In some north European countries, for instance, the government reportedly imposes 100,000-euro penalties for minor traffic violations if the person who commits it is the chairman of large enterprise.

All this is about what kind of society Korea should have in the long run: an unjust, polarizing sort of capitalism where all but a fraction of people are unhappy, or a more equitable community that encourages fair competition after resolving basic needs of its members. For most Koreans, the answer should be obvious.

Interesting contents

Taboola 후원링크

Recommended Contents For You

Taboola 후원링크