Why Trump needs smart-power diplomacy

image

U.S. President Donald Trump went to war against Iran in an effort to dismantle Tehran's highly enriched uranium infrastructure and to prevent Iranian crude oil exports to China. His war policy, in a sense, seeks to rebalance power in the Middle East by maintaining regional peace and security by resorting to coercive power, rather than employing smart-power diplomacy.

What does smart-power diplomacy mean? It aims principally to maximize strategic deterrence and sustainable persuasion in negotiations, as well as to preemptively remove the potential of an enlarged regional war and to reduce the existing military power of Iran and its ambitions of predominance in the region.

Having suffered a setback in the midterm elections as the Democratic Party regained control of Congress, Trump faces a need to reassess his diplomatic style and adopt a different diplomatic posture — one grounded in smart-power diplomacy, with greater emphasis on the strategic application of soft power rather than on military coercion and hard power. This shift in foreign policy priorities including diplomatic skills would have created opportunities for peaceful engagement, regional stability and mutually beneficial outcomes. Ultimately, he bombed several uranium facilities, but failed to fully destroy them.

Why, then, has such a shift become particularly imperative at this juncture?

First, Trump spent billions of dollars of U.S. taxpayers' money to fund an unsuccessful war. Many Americans felt indignation at the war, creating social splits and driving the Republican Party into an electoral loss.

Second, the prices of daily necessities, including oil, have skyrocketed because of rising crude oil costs and the partial destruction of oil refinery facilities in the Middle East.

Third, the freedom of navigation in the Strait of Hormuz has been closed, remaining in a state of vulnerability that has disrupted the regional and global economy.

Fourth, Trump's hasty war policy has opened a venue for instability, because mediations by Pakistan and Qatar have all failed, and Iran has refused to accept a memorandum of understating (MOU) aimed at a ceasefire. In the end, Gulf states have set a defensive wartime front against Iran. The chances of a ceasefire now look gloomy and remote.

Fifth, it opened the door for a proxy war by outside powers directly and geopolitically concerned in the competition for power. China and Russia appear to be engaged in a proxy war competing for predominance over the Middle East.

Sixth, Trump must be compelled to understand why NATO members refused to help him in his war. It was a preemptive war against Iran, with no efforts to first employ smart-power diplomacy. This manner of war initiated by Trump makes the war more complicated. Three countries — the U.S., Iran and Israel — now remain in an awkward situation. Trump needs to persuade NATO members to join the war by leveraging smart-power diplomacy.

Seventh, the U.S.' coercion and containment strategy lasted over some 40 years, but its strategy to weaken Iran produced shabby results.

Eighth, the 60-day MOU prepared by the Trump administration lacked realistic, mutually beneficial proposals, while Iran has labeled the U.S. as the “Great Satan.”

In sum, the Trump administration, having placed commercial interests above broader normative principles, appears reluctant to pursue a diplomatic resolution to the conflict. Instead, Trump seems intent on sustaining the military campaign until Iran’s highly enriched uranium facilities have been dismantled, and establishing the rebalance of power profitable to the Western world while removing Chinese and Russian influence.

This author would recommend that Trump maximize smart-power diplomacy by strategically combining and leveraging soft and hard power. This certainly will open mutually benefitial venues in the protracted war. The Trump administration must strategically and tactically employ smart-power diplomacy and its own potential capacity to end the war in an effort to prevent Iran from becoming a nuclear-armed country and to restore free and safe navigation in the Strait of Hormuz.

Heo Mane, professor emeritus at Pusan National University, is a former president of the Korean Society of Contemporary European Studies. The views expressed in this article are his own.

Interesting contents

Taboola 후원링크

Recommended Contents For You

Taboola 후원링크