New Year to be 'Twilight Zone' between inflation, disinflation

image

As we welcome the new year, it is worth reflecting on a year that saw financial markets undergo multiple phases of schizophrenic behavior. The year 2023 began with the safest assumption that the Chinese economy would blast out from its zero-covid restrictions. The second slam dunk projection was the U.S. economy finally hitting recession, with many anticipating it to strike around midyear. As we all know by now, the opposite of both scenarios happened, taking equity investors on a rollercoaster ride. For fixed-income investors, inflation swung from complacency to panic several times before concluding with a dovish consensus. The year 2023 could be aptly called the year of the "Twilight Zone," where investors found it almost impossible to pinpoint the phase between inflation and disinflation.

For the coming year, we begin with the simple thesis that heightened geopolitical risk and U.S.-China tensions will combine to cause lingering inflationary pressures despite the recent hints of rate cuts from the U.S. central bank. Another critical consideration is that deglobalization is reflected in the diverging fortunes of economies. Historically, major economies are synchronized to global business cycles led by the U.S. central bank, which guides monetary policies and sets the policy path for other central banks.

In this cycle, however, there is rising confidence that the U.S. is possibly achieving a soft landing, to the surprise of many. At the same time, many consider Europe to be facing a mild version of stagflation. Finally, China, the main engine of global growth for the past two decades, is seeing an early stage of Japan-like deflation. On the positive side, Japan is seemingly coming out of its deflation trap labeled the "lost decades." Japan's changing fortunes are helped by rising property prices boosting the domestic economy and the weak yen helping its exporters. South Korea is showing a mixed bag of all four symptoms, leading to a policy conundrum for the coming year. One common trait shared by all of the above nations is the dangerous politicization of economic policies.

The growing politicization of economic figures has managed to avoid public scrutiny for the past few decades, masked by the ultra-easy monetary policies and decades of booming growth. Now that inflation is out of the genie bottle and monetary easing is no longer the default option, the traditional macro data is being micro-managed for political reasons more than ever. We identify three primary economic data points most manipulated and politicized: interest rates (central bank), GDP (recession), and CPI (inflation).

First, on interest rates, the U.S. economy's resilience and the bull market we have observed for most of last year go against all we understand about economic cycles and interest rates. However, the underappreciated reason is that, outside of official interest rates, other economic policy tools are still accommodative. The central bank balance sheet is still massively above the level seen before the subprime crisis, while fiscal spending is rising, not falling for most economies.

Second, the definition of 'recession' is increasingly a misleading term. The official definition of a recession as two consecutive quarters of negative GDP growth is hardly the measure of an economy's health. But for politicians, it is political suicide to take the blame for the hardships that a recession symbolizes. Policies founded on avoiding recession through stop-gap measures are one of the reasons for the debt spiral and misallocation of capital, which will drag down long-term growth. The importance of preventing recession applies not just to politicians but also to central bankers, who consider it to be a testament to their competence. It cannot be a coincidence that the recent surprise dovish turn from the U.S. FOMC arrives just in time for the coming presidential election.

 

The final macro data point to question is the consumer price index (CPI) as a measure of inflation. For decades, the "Japanification" of the world was assumed under the weight of declining demographics and growing dependence on debt to produce growth. Within a couple of years, the discussion of deflation shifted from Japan to China and South Korea. The narrative on Japan's struggles of the past decades is quickly turning positive, with some even arguing that its deflation has been terrible for economic growth but positively affected social balance and harmony. The justification for politicizing economic policies is visibly gaining support around the world.

After decades of deflation, Japan is showing gradual improvements in birth rates, expansion of businesses, and recovery in the property market. Japan's structural headwinds, comprising plummeting birth rates, strong currency and sinking property market prices, are all reversing in a positive direction. There are some obvious parallels between Japan, China and South Korea, but there are also critical differences that policymakers must examine to avoid decades of slumping growth stagnation. For many years, South Korea was considered to be following the lead of Japan on its structural debt trap and low growth. As both South Korea and China's demographics plummet to a record low, they must consider much more aggressive action to avoid a similar fate that befell Japan three decades ago.

Peter S. Kim is a managing director of the KB Financial Group.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Interesting contents

Taboola 후원링크

Recommended Contents For You

Taboola 후원링크