South Korea: A pushover no more

By Sean O'Malley
President Yoon Suk Yeol made headlines recently for his remarks regarding the situations of Ukraine and Taiwan in an interview with Reuters that led to his upbraiding by the governments of Russia and China as well as the Democratic Party of Korea's (DPK) leader, Lee Jae-myung. Distortions of the president's remarks aside, it seemed a fairly deft bit of diplomacy from the world's tenth largest economy, and contrary to some views, does not seem to further damage inter-Korean relations.
Government leaders often use media interviews to signal intentions or float the possibility of policy changes to come. This can be dangerous if the leader strays too far from traditional policy. In 2001 for example, former U.S. President George W. Bush stated that the United States would do “whatever it took to help Taiwan defend herself.” Many around the world felt the former president had ended U.S. adherence to the One-China policy, a step too far, and the White House had to walk back his remarks.
In the case of President Yoon, however, no major policy shift can be noted. He simply seems to have stated some uncomfortable truths; truths that needed voicing to raise South Korea's stature on the global stage.
On the war in Ukraine, President Yoon stated that South Korean lethal aid is conditioned on the occurrence of “large-scale attacks on civilians, massacre or serious violations of the laws of war.” Even if such conditions are met, he did not guarantee lethal support, instead opting for an admission that it “might be difficult for us [South Korea] to insist only on humanitarian or financial support.” This is far from any commitment to intervention in Ukraine.
In fact, the International Criminal Court has already issued an arrest warrant for Russia's President Vladimir Putin on suspicion of unlawful deportation of Ukrainian children to Russia. Mass graves attributed to Russian atrocities against civilians and admissions by former Wagner Group soldiers of their participation in numerous instances of mass murder in Ukraine, are all in the public sphere. So far, none of these atrocities rise to the level of South Korean participation in providing lethal military aid to Ukraine.
Nonetheless, the Russian response was swift and slightly unhinged with former President Dmitry Medvedev threatening to send Russia's latest weapons to North Korea. The Russian state has repeatedly stated it is not targeting civilians in Ukraine, so unless the Russian state is planning large-scale civilian atrocities, something it claims it is not, then President Yoon can be seen by the Russian state as pledging not to provide lethal aid to Ukraine, as the conditions would never likely be met.
Nevertheless, the president's statement sent an important signal to Washington before President Yoon's summit with U.S. President Joe Biden. It signals that South Korea clearly hears the calls for greater participation in Ukraine, and it signals that South Korea will provide support in the most egregious violations of international norms. However, it also clearly implies that Seoul will determine the severity of any violations itself and will not just follow the U.S.' lead.
President Yoon's statements on Taiwan are similar. To paraphrase the president: “we together with the international community absolutely oppose” any “attempts to change the status quo by force.” This is hardly revelatory and is in line with China's own preference for peaceful unification. The president's further statement that the Taiwan issue “is a global issue” is also simply factual. The world's great powers have an interest in keeping the Taiwan Strait open, so it is not simply a Chinese domestic issue, something the Chinese Communist Party knows well.
As for damaging inter-Korean relations, the accusation seems nonsensical. North Korea has staged nearly 80 missile tests since the beginning of 2022, cut off the cross-border hotline, is apparently trying to sell off Kaesong Industrial Complex assets to Chinese investors, and of course blew up the inter-Korean liaison office in 2020. The Kim Jong-un regime has not responded to any outreach of aid by the Yoon administration since it came to office.
One could weakly make the case that this will drive Russia to further support the North. It just might, but that hardly garners a change in current relations. Chairman Kim's military-first policy has had numerous successes lately, far too many to make denuclearization or any other grand negotiating schemes workable. He was already using the war in Ukraine to get closer to Russia, and the Russians have shown few qualms in supporting the North. May Russia eventually break U.N. sanctions to further support the North? Perhaps, but North Korea's continuous breakthroughs in military technologies indicate it is doing just fine with or without Russia's largesse.
The complaint by DPK leader Lee that “offering military support to a region in conflict is an act that harms the national interest and we should never do it” would seem laughable if not so hypocritically dangerous. South Korea is still at war with North Korea, a country that has not denounced unification by force. To say that the illegal war of aggression via invasion is not in South Korea's national interest seems ignorant or delusional. South Koreans would be the first to call for lethal aid if North Korea invades again, and they would likely cite a global interest in upholding the international norm of territorial integrity. The fact that the leader of the so-called Democratic Party sees the invasion of another democracy by an authoritarian neighbor as of no interest to South Korea is dumbfounding.
President Yoon's remarks were undoubtedly a step out from the back row of diplomacy. He was able to signal to the United States that if the need arises due to egregious behavior by Russia that he would consider lethal aid to Ukraine, while at the same time signaling to both Russia and China that South Korea would stay on the sidelines if they maintain the status quo. Far from the major shift in policy that distortions have claimed, this seems a solid bit of diplomacy through the media that signals South Korea will not remain a pushover forever when it comes to these major global issues.
Sean O'Malley (seanmo@dongseo.ac.kr) is a professor of international studies at Dongseo University, where he teaches classes on international relations, U.S.-Korea Relations and the European Union
.