Slump Takes Air Out of New Towns
Ambitious Metropolitan Redevelopment Projects Turn Into White Elephants
By Kim Tong-hyung
Staff Reporter
Seoul spent lavishly on ambitious urban development projects in recent years to revive fast-decaying city centers starving for investment.
However, with a slumping real estate market and collapsing house values making property owners reluctant to splurge on a facelift, the ``New Town'' project looks to have hit a rough patch.
In what would have been unimaginable just a year ago, a group of residents from Heukseok-dong, central Seoul, filed a complaint to the country's Administrative Appeals Commission calling for the Seoul Metropolitan Government to withdraw their neighborhoods from redevelopment plans.
The complaint was signed by 270 residents from areas 1, 2, 7 and 9 from Heukseok-dong's ``urban improvement areas'' that Seoul City and the Dongjak-gu ward office decided to include as New Town sites in September last year.
The residents claim that the New Town project would only drive many of them away from their current neighborhoods, as they would additionally need to spend around 200 million won (about $149,000) to 300 million won per unit to resettle into the new houses.
The thought of paying the extra money, set by subtracting the evaluated value of the old houses from the selling prices of the new ones, would have been easier to swallow just months ago when the local real estate market still had a pulse.
However, with property values plunging amid the recent economic turmoil, an expensive upgrade doesn't sound so reasonable to some house owners.
For example, an owner of a 66-square-meter villa in Heukseok-dong would receive about 200 million won in land compensation after his or her neighborhood is redeveloped under the New Town project. However, it would take around 450 million to buy a new house of comparable size after the project is completed.
``To be listed as an urban development area, the law requires that more than 60 percent of the buildings in that certain area must be more than 20 years old, but Huekseok-dong's area 1, 7 and 9 doesn't meet such standards,'' said Noh Su-wan, one of the residents who participated in the complaint. Should the appeals commission reject their demands, claimants are considering taking the matter to court, Noh said.
``And you could also say that 20-year threshold is unreasonable, when considering that most of the buildings were constructed using concrete and steel beams,'' he said.
Obviously, the claimants don't speak for all of Heukseok-dong residents, and their legal action reflects an ugly rift within the community over clashing interests.
However, growing resistance might prove to be enough to derail the redevelopment projects, which, by law, requires approval from at least 75 percent of the area's residents.
Heukseong-dong is not the only area where the New Town project is meeting mixed reactions. According to real estate watchers, disputes have emerged in more than 20 of the planned redevelopment sites.
Residents from Junghwa-dong and Jangwi-dong are planning collective action to block the redevelopment project in their areas, with the Junghwa-dong group even threatening to take the issue to the Constitutional Court.
Area residents in Dongbingo-dong are also vocal in their opposition to the New Town project for the Yongsan district, although it has more to do with complaints over the facelift of adjacent Bogwang-dong.
Experts believe that the New Town project could be delayed in many areas, with residents tightening their spending due to skidding property value.
``Areas like Garak-dong have already seen the redevelopment process slowed, as more people realize they may not be able to afford the new houses,'' said Park Won-gap of Speed Bank, a property market research group.
``The problems could get bigger and last for an extended period unless the real estate market rebounds,'' he said.