Fighting for a just clause

Park Jung-won
Im Jong-seok, who served as chief of staff to South Korea’s former President Moon Jae-in, caused a major stir last month by proposing the coexistence of South and North Korea as two separate states, saying “Let us not pursue unification!” He added the proviso that these should be two peaceful states, not hostile ones, as described by North Korean leader Kim Jong-un.
Nevertheless, adopting this position, which conflicts with a basic clause in South Korea’s constitution, invites criticism that it will only help North Korea’s strategic aims.
In January, Kim declared that South Korea is not a country with a special relationship to his own, but is rather a purely foreign country and primary enemy. Kim then called for an amendment to the North’s constitution to reflect this.
To the North Korean regime, South Korea is no longer considered a nation of compatriots living under a different system of governance, but instead a target that can be destroyed with nuclear weapons, occupied and incorporated into its territory.
While the “Korean wave” phenomenon of cultural popularity has spread even into North Korea’s “hermit kingdom,” the North’s regime believes that the idea of the two Koreas being a single ethnic nation longing for unification poses a critical threat to its security. From the North’s perspective, the two-state argument serves its overarching purpose of regime survival. Still, it is odd for a former South Korean government official to take a similar stance.
In 1974, East Germany advocated for different nationalities and states between itself and West Germany, which West Germany firmly rejected. East Germany interpreted the Basic Treaty, signed in 1972 by the two governments, as a permanent division treaty, and removed a unification clause through a constitutional amendment two years later. It claimed a separate national status distinct from West Germany, declaring the German people divided into socialist and capitalist nations. In contrast, West Germany maintained that even after the Basic Treaty was signed, East Germany was not recognized as a state under international law. The West German Federal Constitutional Court interpreted that although Article 6 of the Basic Treaty specified noninterference in internal affairs, West Germany’s constitutional obligation to protect East German residents continued, in line with the West German Basic Law.
According to the territory clause of South Korea’s constitution, its normative effect extends to the entire territory of North Korea. The unification clause specifies the value-oriented goal of unification under a liberal democratic order and the condition of a peaceful means of achieving that goal. Interpreting these constitutional articles comprehensively, South Korea’s Supreme Court has ruled that inter-Korean relations are not state-to-state relations, and that North Korea holds a dual status as both an antistate organization and a partner for dialogue and cooperation toward unification.
Responding to President Yoon Suk Yeol’s criticism of his two-state theory, Im argued that Yoon’s stance aligns with North Korea’s hostile version of this theory. He interpreted Yoon’s remarks about pursuing unification through freedom as an intention to pursue unification by force, implying that this idea is rooted in the pursuit of the North Korean regime’s collapse. He asserted that establishing peace quickly, with free exchange and cooperation between the two states, is the most realistic approach, urging a focus solely on "peace" by acknowledging the reality of their division.
Is Im unaware, or unwilling to acknowledge, that the cause of the breach of the peace on the Korean Peninsula is the North Korean regime, which has developed nuclear weapons and engaged in repeated provocations against the South?
Despite the former Moon government’s summits and peace agreements with the North, true peace was never achieved. During that time, North Korea consolidated and advanced its nuclear and missile capabilities. Any declaration of peace in South Korea is futile as long as the threat of the North’s nuclear missiles exists. Believing that giving up on the idea of unification can bring peace to the Korean Peninsula is an illusion.
Above all, Im, who prides himself in having been devoted to the unification movement throughout his life, must realize that peace is not an independent value that exists on its own. Instead, it is a variable defined by other values and principles. Peace must necessarily be established based on universal values such as freedom, human rights, civil liberties and liberal democracy. Peace is not the ultimate end in itself, but rather only holds true meaning when it is governed by those ideals. Despots such as Hitler and Stalin, and more recently Vladimir Putin and Kim Jong-un, have all spoken of peace, but certainly never subscribed to the values that would ensure it.
The recognition of North and South Korea as two separate states would likely require the abolition of the South Korean constitution’s territory clause, possibly also leading to the removal of the unification clause. Ultimately, this aligns with the concept of permanent division. It also risks creating legal obstacles to protecting North Korean defectors and forfeiting important constitutional grounds for South Korea’s involvement in North Korean issues such as a sudden regime change.
The special relationship position, viewing North and South Korea not as two separate states but as eventual unification partners, has to a certain extent contributed to mutual acceptance among residents and eased tensions. If South Korea abandons this position simply because North Korea has done so, it will remove incentives for partnership and could foment hostility. Discussions about shifting inter-Korean relations to state-to-state relations should be approached with caution. Such a transition is not necessary until North Korea adopts a system based on a liberal democratic order.
Issues of unification and inter-Korean relations must be understood and approached from the perspective of respecting human dignity and promoting freedom, which are part of the universal progress of civilization. This is a gravely important duty assigned by the South Korean constitution. Unification of the Korean Peninsula is an indispensable dream that should be pursued until it becomes a reality. It is a vision that must never be abandoned.
Park Jung-won (park_jungwon@hotmail.com), Ph.D. in law from the London School of Economics (LSE), is a professor of international law at Dankook University.