The Korea Times close
National
  • Politics
  • Foreign Affairs
  • Multicultural Community
  • Defense
  • Environment & Animals
  • Law & Crime
  • Society
  • Health & Science
Business
  • Tech
  • Bio
  • Companies
Finance
  • Companies
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Cryptocurrency
Opinion
  • Editorial
  • Columns
  • Thoughts of the Times
  • Cartoon
  • Today in History
  • Blogs
  • Tribune Service
  • Blondie & Garfield
  • Letter to President
  • Letter to the Editor
Lifestyle
  • Travel & Food
  • Trends
  • People & Events
  • Books
  • Around Town
  • Fortune Telling
Entertainment
& Arts
  • K-pop
  • Films
  • Shows & Dramas
  • Music
  • Theater & Others
Sports
World
  • SCMP
  • Asia
Video
  • Culture
  • People
  • News
Photos
  • Photo News
  • Darkroom
  • The Korea Times
  • search
  • Site Map
  • E-paper
  • Subscribe
  • Register
  • LogIn
search close
  • The Korea Times
  • search
  • Site Map
  • E-paper
  • Subscribe
  • Register
  • LogIn
search close
Opinion
  • Yun Byung-se
  • Kim Won-soo
  • Ahn Ho-young
  • Kim Sang-woo
  • Yang Moo-jin
  • Yoo Yeon-chul
  • Peter S. Kim
  • Daniel Shin
  • Jeffrey D. Jones
  • Jang Daul
  • Song Kyung-jin
  • Park Jung-won
  • Cho Hee-kyoung
  • Park Chong-hoon
  • Kim Sung-woo
  • Donald Kirk
  • John Burton
  • Robert D. Atkinson
  • Mark Peterson
  • Eugene Lee
  • Rushan Ziatdinov
  • Lee Jong-eun
  • Chyung Eun-ju
  • Troy Stangarone
  • Jason Lim
  • Casey Lartigue, Jr.
  • Bernard Rowan
  • Steven L. Shields
  • Deauwand Myers
  • John J. Metzler
  • Andrew Hammond
  • Sandip Kumar Mishra
  • Lee Seong-hyon
  • Park Jin
  • Cho Byung-jae
Thu, August 18, 2022 | 01:25
Andrew Salmon
Resilience of the Kims
Posted : 2015-10-12 17:07
Updated : 2015-10-12 17:15
Print Preview
Font Size Up
Font Size Down
By Andrew Salmon

Last weekend, global eyes were glued to TV screens as North Korea's Workers' Party celebrated its 70th anniversary in depressingly predictable style.

Many, viewing this bizarre mutation ― a communist-polity-turned-monarchy ― doubtless wondered: "How can such a brutal, backward-looking regime resist all modern trends and continue in its third-generation?"

In fact, a widespread assumption that the Kim regime is unviable, long-term, prevails.

The White House, Blue House and innumerable pundits apparently believe that North Korea must inevitably "collapse," "implode" or "rise." Perhaps military pragmatists will seize power? Perhaps a bold insider will assassinate Kim Jong-un? Perhaps poor, desperate citizens will rebel?

Once this happens (the assumption goes), there will be instability, chaos or even civil war ― but then unification will dawn and the peninsula will advance into sunlit uplands.

Alas. If we examine recent history's worst, most ruthless, most totalitarian dictatorships, there is no proof that good prevails, that dictators inevitably meet justice.

For his murder of millions of Jews and Slavs, Adolf Hitler is reviled as history's most evil man, but although he dragged Germany into a moral and physical abyss, he was not overthrown by Germans. He survived assassination plots; an attempted military coup drew little support and collapsed immediately. Most citizens remained loyal and his soldiers fought to the end, even while Germany was pulverized from all sides. Hitler only shot himself when the Red Army stormed his ruined capital.

Hitler's nemesis, Josef Stalin, killed millions with preventable famines, purges and gulags that effectively removed opposition/potential opposition. Despite these deaths, and the mass slaughter resulting from his inept command in the early stages of Germany's invasion of the USSR, no internal player moved to topple him. After World War II, he remained in charge, dying of a heart attack.

Mao Zedong may have buried even more than both Hitler and Stalin, as a side-effect and result of his catastrophic policies. But when party elements challenged him following his disastrous "Great Leap Forward," he unleashed the "Cultural Revolution" and successfully marginalized them. He died of a heart attack, his position unchallenged.

Pol Pot, the murderous radical who oversaw Cambodia's genocide, was not challenged during the mass killings in that country. His end, like Hitler's, resulted from an external (Vietnamese) invasion. After successive defeats, his party and military crumbled. A subordinate placed him under house arrest, where he died of a heart attack or (perhaps) poison.

Saddam Hussein beggared his oil-rich country with disastrous wars against Iran and Kuwait. Yet even after the Gulf War defeat, he ruthlessly mastered rebellions in Iraq's north and south and was only (finally) dislodged by a full-scale invasion.

So, however murderous and disastrous their leadership, Stalin and Mao retained power, were never seriously challenged from within, and died peacefully. Hitler maintained Germany's loyalty; his death was a direct result of external invasion. Pol Pot and Hussein fell for the same reason.

Italy's Mussolini, Rumania's Ceaucescu and South Korea's Park were killed by internal players, while Spain's Franco, Chile's Pinochet and South Korea's Chun oversaw power transitions. But none of these leaders were as murderous as the above dictators.

Nor were their states as totalitarian as North Korea. Kim Il-sung died peacefully, unchallenged and venerated. Many South Koreans were convinced that their Northern brethren would reject Kim Jong-il's leadership after his father's death. Wrong.

American pundits then predicted collapse following withdrawal of economic support from European ex-communist states and lethal famines. Wrong again. Two military revolts took place (the "Frunze Academy" and "Ninth Corps" coups); neither came close to success. Despite presiding over his country's plunge into famine and poverty, Kim's power remained intact and he died peacefully, aboard his luxury train.

Now, we confront a third Kim.

Because he has replaced, exiled or executed several officials and generals, some believe his powerbase is fragile. Nonsense. By such logic, Hitler and Stalin could never have survived. Stalin wiped out hundreds of thousands of officials and officers; Hitler sacked countless commanders and killed thousands. In totalitarian dictatorships, terror is effective at dissuading dissenters and crushing dissent.

Let us stop daydreaming about a coup, "implosion," or rebellion: Power grabs generally fail in totalitarian dictatorships; North Korea's economy is growing; and the citizenry lack power to mobilize or challenge the state.

As for external overthrow, there is no guerilla army massing on the border, and given Beijing's support for Pyongyang (and endless other reasons) a Seoul-Washington invasion is a non-starter.

So, it is time for a rethink. We may hope that justice ― violent or otherwise ― awaits Kim, but recent history suggests otherwise. Dictators are not necessarily fated to fall.

Kim may be on Pyongyang's throne for another four decades. Given this, let us map out long-term policies based on the real situation and real politick, rather than indulging in wishful thinking and unification fantasies.

Andrew Salmon is a Seoul-based reporter and author. Reach him at andrewcsalmon@yahoo.co.uk.

Emailandrewcsalmon@yahoo.co.uk Article ListMore articles by this reporter
 
LG
  • Samsung's defective washing machine fans consumer concerns
  • [INTERVIEW] Moon rallies int'l support for unification of two Koreas
  • Standard Chartered Bank chief to visit Seoul in late August
  • Envoy raises awareness of Korea among Serbian public
  • 'Labor law should be changed in line with Fourth Industrial Revolution'
  • [INTERVIEW] Data essential for 'evidence-based decisions': Statistics Korea commissioner
  • Yoon confident about Korea hosting World Expo 2030
  • What polls don't say about Yoon
  • Yoon opposes forceful change to status quo in North Korea
  • Bitcoin's role expected to expand as investors circumvent capital controls: Bithumb research chief
  • Interactive News
  • With tough love,
  • 'Santa dogs' help rebuild burnt forests in Andong
  • 'Santa dogs' help rebuild burnt forests in Andong
  • A tale of natural wine
    • 2PM's Lee Jun-ho proves versatility at 'Before Midnight' concert 2PM's Lee Jun-ho proves versatility at 'Before Midnight' concert
    • 'Confidential Assignment 2' has even more action, humor 'Confidential Assignment 2' has even more action, humor
    • [INTERVIEW] Director of 'A Model Family' on blending Korean and European-style thrillers [INTERVIEW] Director of 'A Model Family' on blending Korean and European-style thrillers
    • Thriller series 'Flower Of Evil' becomes first K-drama to be remade in India Thriller series 'Flower Of Evil' becomes first K-drama to be remade in India
    • 'Extraordinary Attorney Woo' to be made into musicals in 2024 'Extraordinary Attorney Woo' to be made into musicals in 2024
    DARKROOM
    • Ice is melting, land is burning

      Ice is melting, land is burning

    • Tottenham 6-3 Team K League

      Tottenham 6-3 Team K League

    • Afghanistan earthquake killed more than 1,000

      Afghanistan earthquake killed more than 1,000

    • Divided America reacts to overturn of Roe vs. Wade

      Divided America reacts to overturn of Roe vs. Wade

    • Namaste: Yogis to celebrate International Yoga Day

      Namaste: Yogis to celebrate International Yoga Day

    The Korea Times
    CEO & Publisher : Oh Young-jin
    Digital News Email : webmaster@koreatimes.co.kr
    Tel : 02-724-2114
    Online newspaper registration No : 서울,아52844
    Date of registration : 2020.02.05
    Masthead : The Korea Times
    Copyright © koreatimes.co.kr. All rights reserved.
    • About Us
    • Introduction
    • History
    • Location
    • Media Kit
    • Contact Us
    • Products & Service
    • Subscribe
    • E-paper
    • Mobile Service
    • RSS Service
    • Content Sales
    • Policy
    • Privacy Statement
    • Terms of Service
    • 고충처리인
    • Youth Protection Policy
    • Code of Ethics
    • Copyright Policy
    • Family Site
    • Hankook Ilbo
    • Dongwha Group