The Korea Times close
National
  • Politics
  • Diplomacy
  • Defense
  • Labor & Environment
  • Law & Crime
  • Health & Welfare
  • Embassy
  • Seoul & Provinces
  • Education
  • Foreign Communities
  • Obituaries
  • Multicultural Youth Award
Biz & Tech
  • Auto
  • IT
  • Game
  • Manufacturing
  • Retail & Food
  • Energy
  • Construction
  • Airlines
Finance
  • Policies
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Banks
  • Non-banks
Opinion
  • Editorial
  • Columns
  • Thoughts of the Times
  • Cartoon
  • Today in History
  • Blogs
  • Tribune Service
  • Blondie & Garfield
Lifestyle
  • Arts
  • Books
  • Travel & Cuisine
  • Trend
  • Fashion
  • Around Town
  • Fortune Telling
  • Translation Award
Entertainment
  • K-pop
  • K-dramas & Shows
  • Movies
  • Music
  • Performances
  • Asia Model Festival
Sports
  • Football
  • Golf
  • Baseball
  • Other Sports
World
  • Asia Pacific
  • Americas
  • Europe & Africa
  • SCMP
Video
  • On the Spot
  • Feature
  • News
Photos
  • Photo News
  • Darkroom
Community
  • The Korea Times
  • all menu
  • search
  • facebookfacebook
  • twittertwitter
  • youtubeyoutube
  • Site Map
  • E-paper
  • Subscribe
  • Register
  • LogIn
search close
  • The Korea Times
  • all menu
  • search
  • facebookfacebook
  • twittertwitter
  • youtubeyoutube
  • Site Map
  • E-paper
  • Subscribe
  • Register
  • LogIn
search close
National
  • Politics
  • Diplomacy
  • Defense
  • Labor & Environment
  • Law & Crime
  • Health & Welfare
  • Embassy
  • Seoul & Provinces
  • Education
  • Foreign Communities
  • Obituaries
  • Multicultural Youth Award
Wed, December 11, 2019 | 20:43
Court Declares MBC Not Guilty on Mad Cow Report in 2008
Posted : 2010-01-20 18:41
Updated : 2010-01-20 18:41
Mail
Print Preview
Font Size Up
Font Size Down
By Park Si-soo
Staff Reporter

The battle between liberal judges versus conservative prosecutors ― a snapshot of a serious ideological divide facing the nation ― is reaching boiling point following the latest judicial ruling clearing a television news team of false reporting on mad cow disease.

A Seoul court cleared MBC TV's investigative journal ``PD Notebook'' on defamation charges, Wednesday, for allegedly wrongly portraying the actions of the Lee Myung-bak government during its talks with Washington to resume U.S. beef imports in 2008.

Cheong Wa Dae refused to comment on the verdict in an apparent show of extreme displeasure.

The ruling came just days after another court acquitted a progressive legislator on charges of violent behavior at the National Assembly, touching off the ideological dispute between the two pillars of the courtroom ― judges and prosecutors.

The feud deepened after an additional court ruling, Tuesday, found a group of ``progressive'' teachers not guilty of engaging in collective action denouncing conservative President Lee last year. Participation in political rallies by teachers is prohibited under current laws.

Conservative-progressive tensions reached a peak Wednesday after the Seoul Central District Court exonerated five MBC staff members ― four program directors and a script writer, who were indicted for defaming government officials in two episodes of PD Notebook that were critical of the Lee administration's decision to resume importing U.S. beef.

In April 2008, the episodes were allegedly based on scientific research that Koreans were genetically susceptible to Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease ― the human form of bovine spongiform encephalopathy, or mad cow disease.

The program criticized then Agriculture Minister Chung Woon-chun and Min Dong-seok, one of the chief negotiators in the beef import deal, for ``ignoring'' the risk of mad cow disease associated with U.S. beef in order to rekindle warmer Korea-U.S. diplomatic ties, which had remained chilly during the 2003-2008 presidency of the liberal Roh Moo-hyun.

The program provoked countless health-conscious citizens to take to major thoroughfares across the country and stage rallies for about three months, forcing President Lee to renegotiate the deal, to make an official apology and to reshuffle the Cabinet to contain his nose-diving approval ratings.

The two state negotiators filed a suit against the five MBC workers, arguing the accused defamed them by distorting the facts, deliberately mistranslating interviews with several Americans and exaggerating the threat of mad cow disease associated with American beef.

``Although there were some exaggerations or errors in translation, it is hard to say they deliberately distorted the facts related to the threat of the disease,'' Judge Mun Sung-gwan said in his ruling.

``As the program criticized the resumption of imports of U.S. beef, based on expert opinion and research results, it cannot be considered to have caused harm to the reputation of the officials.''

The prosecution said that the ruling didn't make sense, adding that it plans to appeal.

``The court's decision is sort of a self-contradiction,'' said a prosecutor familiar with the case. In fact, a court ordered MBC to air a correction over the two episodes in June last year, saying part of the story had been confirmed to be exaggerated.

MBC admitted errors in translation and formally apologized for airing incorrect information.

The protest against the resumption of U.S. beef imports was initiated by health-conscious citizens, but later transformed into a battlefield for those harboring antagonism toward the conservative President Lee.

Liberal news outlets, which enjoyed their heyday during the Roh Moo-hyun presidency, supported MBC, praising the nation's second largest TV station as a crusader for the pro-democracy, anti-government movement, while conservative media condemned MBC for misleading the public.

The ruling Grand National Party immediately condemned the verdict, saying, ``The decision goes against common sense, dealing yet another blow to the judiciary.''

pss@koreatimes.co.kr
One Judge Reignites War of Ideology
Whether it was predictable or not, Judge Lee Dong-yeon at the Seoul Southern District Court has brought the Korean judiciary into chaos, which is unlikely to end in the foreseeable...








 
 
  • number164 Vietnamese students vanish in South Korea
  • numberVoluntary departure: Re-entry to be allowed for illegal aliens who leave Korea by June
  • numberSeoul's home prices to continue on upward spiral
  • numberAir pollution chokes South Korea [PHOTOS]
  • numberKorean's first-ever Filipino street food tour at QUIAPO MARKET in Manila [VIDEO]
  • numberFootwear malfunction in front of Kim Il-sung
  • numberEx-Daewoo Group Chairman Kim Woo-choong dies at 82
  • numberMoon to hold summits with Xi, Abe
  • numberUltrafine dust rising to 'very bad' levels in Seoul
  • numberDaughter of Herald ex-head gets suspended jail term for drug use
  • Kim Gun-mo accused of rape Kim Gun-mo accused of rape
  • TWICE Jihyo injured at airport due to fans TWICE Jihyo injured at airport due to fans
  • TV show airs singer Kim Gun-mo's love story despite sexual assault claim TV show airs singer Kim Gun-mo's love story despite sexual assault claim
  • Yang Joon-il, a musician living ahead of his time, finally recognized 30 year later Yang Joon-il, a musician living ahead of his time, finally recognized 30 year later
  • U2 says 'women of the world unite' in Korea U2 says 'women of the world unite' in Korea
DARKROOM
  • Children deserve better

    Children deserve better

  • Global climate change: time is running out

    Global climate change: time is running out

  • CA cave fire burns more than 4,300 acres

    CA cave fire burns more than 4,300 acres

  • No money, no hope: South Korea's 'Dirt Spoons'

    No money, no hope: South Korea's 'Dirt Spoons'

  • Hong Kong democrats score historic victory

    Hong Kong democrats score historic victory

  • About Korea Times
  • CEO Message
  • Times History
  • Content Sales
  • Media Kit
  • Contact Us
  • Location
  • Privacy Statement
  • Terms of Service
  • Mobile Service
  • RSS Service
  • Ombudsman
  • hankookilbo
  • Dongwha Group
  • Code of Ethics
Copyright