my timesThe Korea Times

Controversy heating up over daily school attendance of first graders

Listen

Cho Hee-yeon, right, the superintendent of the Seoul Metropolitan Office of Education, checks a student's temperature at Seryun Elementary School in Seoul in this Feb. 3 file photo. Korea Times photo by Hong In-ki

By Bahk Eun-ji

Controversy is heating up over a suggestion made by Seoul's education chief, that first graders in elementary and middle schools resume daily school attendance from Oct. 12.

Some parents and educators said in-person classes cannot be delayed any longer as the number of low performing students has increased since schools started to provide online lessons, while others are concerned of the high possibility of classrooms becoming virus hotbeds if too many students gather in one place.

The controversy has come as the prolonged period of remote teaching has not solved the problems of poor basic education, educational gaps, and childcare, while there is a tight confrontation between those who are worried about the possibility of COVID-19 infections and those who cannot afford to postpone the start of in-person classes until the end of the pandemic.

According to the Seoul Metropolitan Office of Education (SMOE), Superintendent Cho Hee-yeon said in a press conference Wednesday, “From Oct. 12, first graders at elementary and middle schools should attend school every day even if the country is operating Level 1 or 2 social distancing measures,” adding, “The SMOE will propose the idea to the Ministry of Education.”

Cho explained that first graders of elementary and middle schools who began new classes have a more urgent need to take in-person classes than those in other grades who have had more time to get used to new schools.

As the became public, controversy over the pros and cons of attending schools physically for first graders of elementary and middle schools has been heating up.

Those who oppose going to school every day argued that improving the quality of remote classes should come first rather than resuming onsite classes as the number of infected students is expected to increase this fall and winter.

Lee Hae-yun, a 40-year-old mother of an elementary school student in Seoul, said “I think the number of confirmed cases will increase after the Chuseok holiday. Isn't it ridiculous to push students to go to school every day in such a situation?” She continued, “There are 30 students in my son's class, so will it be possible to maintain social distancing between them every day?”

However, those who are in favor of their children attending school, argued that there is no reason to keep them at home as many people are already maintaining their daily lives by going to work and sending their children to private cram schools.

A 37-year-old father of a first grader of an elementary school in Seoul, who wished to be identified only by his surname Ku, said “There is no room for improvement in the current remote classes, and I really want to send her to school every day. It's a problem with taking care of a child when they are not going to school, so our daily routine becomes a mess.”

In response to Cho's suggestion, the education ministry said the government will judge the situation after carefully observing the spread of the virus after the Chuseok Holiday.

“We respect the SMOE's proposal, but we will have to see the situation as the Chuseok holiday will pass before a decision can be made,” said Park Baeg-beom, vice minister of education, in a press briefing Thursday.

All students in the metropolitan area have been having online classes since Aug. 26, due to a resurgence in virus cases. Earlier this month the measure, originally scheduled to end Sept. 11, was extended until Sept. 20 to contain the spread of the coronavirus.

Schools around the nation are required to operate quarantine measures. Attendance is capped at one-third of capacity in elementary and middle schools and two-thirds in high schools to guarantee social distancing.