'Nuclear plants caused thyroid cancer'

A member of an anti-nuclear power group talks about a class action filed against the Korea Hydro & Nuclear Power Corp. by 301 people suffering from thyroid cancer during a media briefing at a law firm in Busan, Tuesday. / Yonhap
301 patients lodge compensation suit against plant operator
By Kim Rahn
In a small town near the Gori Nuclear Plant in Busan, 15 of 711 residents have thyroid cancer. In some families, there are more than two people suffering from it.
All the villages near the country’s four nuclear power plants show that there are much higher numbers of people with thyroid cancer than the national average, and this, environmental groups claim, is not a coincidence.
According to the Korean Federation for Environmental Movement, the percentage of thyroid cancer patients was 0.42 percent in Korea as of 2011, but the rate for villages near the plants was 1.61 percent.
Based on this data, 301 villagers suffering from thyroid cancer filed a class-action suit on Tuesday against the operator of the nuclear plants ― the Korea Hydro & Nuclear Power Corp. (KHNP) ― to demand compensation. They claim their disease was the result of years of exposure to radiation from the plants.
The plaintiffs live within a 10-kilometer radius of the nuclear plants.
“In Korea, an average of 68.7 people in 100,000 were found to have had thyroid cancer in 2011. However, in the towns within a 10-kilometer radius from the Gori plant, the risk of getting the disease was six times higher,” said Lee Sang-hong, an official from the environmental group’s Gyeongju branch that helps the plaintiffs.
He said there may be more victims because not all thyroid cancer patients in the regions took part in the suit, while others may be unaware that they have the disease.
Of the 301 patients of the class action, 191 were residents near the Gori plant; 46 near the Wolsong in Gyeongju, North Gyeongsang Province; 34 near Hanbit in Yeonggwang, South Jeolla Province; and 30 near Hanul in Uljin, North Gyeongsang Province.
Over 95 percent of them were diagnosed with the cancer in the last 10 years. Some 83 percent were women, and those in their 40s or 50s make up 65.3 percent of the total.
Each of the patients demanded 15 million won in compensation, while their spouses demanded 3 million won each, and their parents or children, 1 million won.
The action comes two months after a local court in Busan ruled in favor of a woman, Park, who filed a compensation suit against the KHNP by claiming she got thyroid cancer after being exposed to radiation for 20 years at her house 7 kilometers from the Gori plant.
In the Oct. 17 ruling, the court ordered the KHNP to pay 15 million won in compensation to Park. It said that the plant operator was responsible if a resident near the plant contracted thyroid cancer after being exposed to radioactivity for a long time, although the levels of radioactivity emitted from the plant was below the set limit, 0.25-1.00 milli-sievert, because it is just a minimum guideline and therefore cannot guarantee the absolute safety of residents.
The KHNP appealed to a high court, claiming that radioactivity from nuclear plants is irrelevant to thyroid cancer. It said that people in any region get 3 milli-sievert of radiation per year from radiation in nature, while the Gori plant emits a maximum radiation level of 0.03 milli-sievert.
It also claimed that people in the regions near the plants did not show a high incidence of other types of cancer; that thyroid cancer attack rates were especially high among women and not equally high among both men and women; and that the rates were not proportional to how long they had lived there.
The civic group plans to collect more alleged victims for a second class-action next year. “The KHNP needs to examine the health of all residents living near nuclear plants and take countermeasures against radioactivity, even though this would be belated,” Lee said.