my timesThe Korea Times
  1. Opinion
  2. Columns
  3. Columnists

Cheating is a symptom of a society that tests the wrong things

Listen

Summary

South Korea’s high-stakes exams and credential-focused hiring can encourage cheating by rewarding performance under narrow test conditions over broader abilities. The latest example was a test taker who used a miniature camera, smartphone and AI to cheat and top the national tax accountant examination. Michael Breen argues that enforcing rules is necessary but insufficient, and that society should reconsider how it defines success. He proposes skills-based hiring and assessments that test judgment, communication and real-world problem-solving, including students’ ability to use and question AI.


Key Facts

  • The College Scholastic Ability Test took place on Thursday, and the article says a student’s performance may affect university admission, job prospects and later opportunities.
  • The article says cheating scandals have also surfaced in university admissions, civil service examinations, academic research, professional qualifications and job or public-office resumes.
  • Breen describes credentials as proxies employers use to assess applicants when they find it difficult to distinguish talent, intelligence, judgment and potential.
  • The article suggests oral examinations, project-based assessments and real-world problem-solving exercises as alternatives to timed tests of recall.
  • Breen says new assessments would need to be fair, scalable and resistant to manipulation.
By Michael Breen
  • Published Nov 19, 2026 3:50 pm KST

Hundreds of thousands of high school students sat the College Scholastic Ability Test (CSAT) on Thursday, in what for many will have been the most consequential few hours of their young lives.

They were told to leave their phones outside, keep their eyes on their own papers and follow rules designed to ensure that everyone played fair.

Meanwhile, authorities have been scrambling to work out how to prevent students from using artificial intelligence (AI) to cheat.

Although AI adds a new component, there is something rather familiar about all this.

Cheating in exams, falsifying credentials and embellishing qualifications have been around forever. Every so often, a scandal surfaces involving university admissions, civil service examinations, academic research, professional qualifications and the resumes of people seeking jobs or public office.

The latest case involving a test taker who made the mistake of cheating too well and coming top in the national tax accountant examination after using a miniature camera, a smartphone and AI to obtain answers is a particularly striking example. It comes as new measures to crack down on cheating in the Test of Proficiency in Korean are under consideration.

You have to wonder how much of it goes on without ever surfacing.

That is because, the problem is not simply one of policing. It is one of culture.

Young people spend years memorizing facts, formulas, vocabulary and prescribed interpretations of texts, only to be judged on how much of that material they can reproduce in a few hours on a particular day. Much of it will be forgotten shortly afterward. Yet a student's performance during Thursday's CSAT may determine which university that student attends, which companies will consider an application and, ultimately, the opportunities available in life.

What message does that system send? That the institution values the student's ability to perform under its particular conditions, rather than the student's curiosity, judgment, creativity, character or ability to solve problems in the real world.

If a student comes to believe that the system is fundamentally indifferent to who he or she really is, it becomes easier to be indifferent to the system's rules. The exam becomes an obstacle to overcome, not an exercise whose integrity is worth protecting.

Cheating remains a moral failure, of course, but it is a failure occurring within a system that has its own moral shortcomings.

The problem goes deep. The obsession with credentials is partly a consequence of the difficulty decision-makers have in assessing value.

Faced with hundreds of applicants, how does an employer distinguish talent, intelligence, judgment and potential? It is easier to look at a university name, grades or a certificate. The credential becomes a proxy for quality, even when it tells us surprisingly little about the person holding it.

I once heard an exasperated academic at a seminar respond to a disagreement with a colleague from a provincial university by saying: "But Dr. Lee, I went to Seoul National University." It was a wonderfully revealing moment. The implication was not that he had made a better argument, but that his credentials should settle the argument. It was rather like a captain pulling rank on a sergeant.

One answer is to punish cheating more severely. Certainly, the rules must be enforced, and those who cheat should face meaningful consequences. But punishment alone will not solve a problem rooted in the way society defines success.

A more promising approach would be for employers to reconsider the importance they attach to credentials.

Some companies are already moving toward skills-based recruitment, practical assessments and hiring people whose abilities can be demonstrated rather than inferred from the university they attended.

The other opportunity is to rethink what examinations look like in the age of AI. If the ability to memorize and reproduce information is increasingly something machines can do, we should be asking what we actually want people to be capable of. Can they ask the right questions? Can they judge whether an answer is reliable? Can they distinguish fact from fiction, weigh competing arguments, communicate clearly and apply knowledge to an unfamiliar problem?

An exam designed to test those abilities might look very different. Students could be given access to AI and asked to demonstrate how they use it, challenge its answers, identify errors and develop their own conclusions.

Oral examinations, project-based assessments and real-world problem-solving exercises might tell us more about someone's abilities than a timed test of recall.

The challenge is to design these assessments in ways that are fair, scalable and resistant to manipulation.

Michael Breen (mike.breen@insightcomms.com) is the author of "The New Koreans." The views expressed here are his own.

Explore More

  • Q.

  • Q.

  • Q.