my timesThe Korea Times

Defense innovation: What is to be done?

Listen

Ahn Ho-young

Ahn Ho-young

The 13th Seoul Defense Dialogue was held in Seoul from Sept. 11 to 12. More than 60 countries participated in the dialogue at the ministerial or vice ministerial level. A large number of important issues for international security were discussed during the two days. One of the issues discussed at the plenary session was defense innovation, for which representatives of the United Kingdom, the United States and Germany participated. I had an opportunity to moderate the session.

Successive Korean governments have pursued defense innovation as a top priority without exception. I was thus curious about the perspectives that the highest defense leaders of the three countries hold on the subject. My curiosity was deepened because of the fact that those three countries have played a determining role for issues of war and peace over the past 100 years.

The first question I raised with them was why ministers consider defense innovation an important issue in today’s context. There were many common denominators in their answers. The predominant concern of the ministers was that the rules-based international order now faces many challenges around the world, a prominent example being the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Their second concern was the development of technology and its application to weapons, including drones, other uncrewed weapon systems and the unrestrained application of artificial intelligence (AI) to warfighting. They also expressed concerns about the extension of the battlefield to space and cyberspace.

I then asked how the three countries pursued defense innovation to meet these challenges. I again found many common denominators in their answers.

First of all, the ministers were firm in their views that defense innovation must be pursued with a sense of urgency. Defense projects usually involve a heavy amount of expenses. For that reason, they usually have to go through many processes of review and deliberations from a project’s conception to the delivery of the end product to the soldiers in the field. The process usually takes a long time, and some projects do not survive the process, which is pejoratively called the “valley of death.” Three ministers were of the view that the process must be simplified for timely delivery of weapon systems to the field.

In this context, the U.S. Deputy Undersecretary of Defense shared her experiences over a program called "Replicator" through which the U.S. could expedite the whole process and reduce the time from seven years, which is the usual time taken for a project of the size, to only one year.

Second, the three ministers spoke in unison that defense innovation must be pursued with emphasis on improving interoperability. As challenges to the global liberal order spread, there are increasing demands for combined military operations among allies both in the Indo-Pacific and in Europe. In such combined operations, interoperability of the weapon systems and training among different members of alliances are key factors determining the outcome of the operations.

In this connection, the minister of defense of the United Kingdom explained efforts made among the AUKUS members (Australia, the United Kingdom and the United States). The minister explained that AUKUS efforts consist of Pillar I, through which the United Kingdom and the United States cooperate with Australia to provide nuclear-powered submarines to Australia; and Pillar II, through which the three countries cooperate on developing defense technologies on cyber, AI, quantum computing and underwater warfighting capability. The U.K. minister stated that Pillar II as well as Pillar I is making good progress, and is expected to further strengthen interoperability of weapon systems among the three countries.

Third, the three ministers agreed that defense innovation must be pursued with a sense of responsibility. New weapon systems often lead to more powerful means of causing damage to human lives. Thus, in developing new weapon systems, it must be considered how to restrain and control their destructive power. At the same time, along with the development of new weapon systems, there must be commensurate improvement in the ethics and sense of responsibility among the political and military leaders using those new weapon systems.

On this point, the three ministers spoke highly of the progress made through the REAIM (responsible AI in the military domain) Seoul Summit held Sept. 9 and 10. The “Blueprint for Action,” a document adopted at the summit, made important progress to balancing the military use of AI with concrete ideas for responsible human control of AI.

Korea is now working hard on Defense Innovation 4.0, the Yoon government’s flagship plan for defense innovation, which emphasizes significantly improving automation and mobility for the military. The three ideas discussed at the defense innovation session of the Seoul Defense Dialogue — namely speed, interoperability and responsibility — are important factors to guide Korea’s defense innovation as well. That’s the reason why defense innovation emerges as another area through which Korea can further strengthen security cooperation with the U.S., the U.K., Germany and other NATO member countries.

Ahn Ho-young is chair professor at Kyungnam University. He served as ambassador to the United States and vice foreign minister.