my timesThe Korea Times

Will North Korea change?

Listen
Ahn Ho-young

Ahn Ho-young

In perusing world history, we sometimes encounter leaders cooperating with each other to resolve a huge challenge facing humanity. After World War II, such cooperation took place between President Ronald Reagan of the U.S. and General Secretary Mikhail Gorbachev of the former Soviet Union.

What we have to note is that such cooperation was possible only after the leaders underwent difficult changes in their perception of the problems facing their nations. Gorbachev was proud of being a true Marxist-Leninist devotee and made an impressive rise in the Soviet Communist Party. He was eventually elected as the General Secretary at the young age of 54.

Once assuming that position, he confounded his colleagues by adopting glasnost and perestroika policies. The genesis of his change came from long experiences of working on agricultural issues. He came to find the inconvenient truth that Soviet agriculture, and the Soviet Union for that matter, could not be sustained without changing the sclerotic central control of Moscow.

Reagan also went through equally impressive changes. He was a devoted anti-communist and made a huge contribution to further strengthening U.S. defense capabilities in the belief of “peace through strength.” In 1983, a Soviet fighter plane shot down a Korean Air passenger flight, killing all 269 passengers. It was soon followed by the large-scale Able Archer, a NATO military exercise in Europe, which ignited Soviet fears and led to the risk of actual military confrontation. These experiences concerned Reagan deeply and made him start on the path of cooperating with Gorbachev to end the Cold War.

Soon after the Singapore summit between U.S. President Donald Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong-un in June 2018, Robert Carlin, a long-time observer of the Korean Peninsula, used the analogy of astrology and made this comment on the relations between Trump, Kim and then-President Moon Jae-in of South Korea, saying, “(the) stars have never quite been in alignment with all the players.”

Such an expectation soon collapsed after the Hanoi summit the following year. It was because North Korea, without adopting the necessary changes in its economic and nuclear strategy, sought only to remove the economic sanctions for superficial changes in its nuclear capability. North Korea soon began to trumpet its development of nuclear weapons and missiles, changed its nuclear doctrine to threaten a preemptive strike against South Korea, declared that North and South Korea no longer share the same root as a nation and South Korea is no more than a hostile nation to be conquered through military subjugation.

Furthermore, North Korea and Russia are developing unprecedentedly close relations after the Russian invasion of Ukraine. North Korea is now believed to get energy, food, other materials and even military technology from Russia. The deepening tension in U.S.-China relations is worried to lead to closer alignment of relations among North Korea, Russia and China.

All of these developments in North Korea and in the regional politics in Northeast Asia do not augur well for North Korea to seek necessary changes in its economic and nuclear strategy. However, for durable peace on the Korean peninsula, we must pursue all the possibilities to promote such changes in North Korea. That is why I often seek the views of North Korean watchers in Seoul on the subject. There emerge several common denominators in my conversation with them.

First of all, the economic impact of the fresh supply of energy, food and other materials from Russia on the North Korean economy will be narrowly limited so long as North Korea does not change its rigid economic policy. Second, the Russian economic assistance that North Korea enjoys for the time being will expire soon after the end of the Ukrainian war. Third, the economic malaise of North Korea cannot be cured without North Korea changing its stifling control over the economy, removing tight control over cross-border economic exchanges and ending the global web of economic sanctions. The economic dead end will lead North Korean citizens, especially the younger generation, to yearn for a freer and better life in South Korea and the outside world, which is already perceived in North Korea as a serious threat to its social and political stability.

The economic, social and political challenges that North Korea experiences today are far greater than the problems the Soviet Union used to face in the 1980s. There are many signs that all of these challenges are forcing North Korea to the brink. These challenges can no longer be suppressed through the closing of its national border or tightening its laws for stricter social control. The only option left for North Korea is to change and open up. South Korea, for the time being, cannot lower its guard to meet the military challenges from the North. At the same time, we must continue to engage North Korea and help it to avoid a hard, calamitous landing.

Ahn Ho-young is chair professor at Kyungnam University. He served as ambassador to the United States.