my timesThe Korea Times
  1. Opinion

The Trump conundrum

Listen
  • Published Oct 5, 2023 4:30 pm KST
  • Updated Oct 5, 2023 4:30 pm KST
 

American politics never ceases to amaze as former President Donald Trump emerges as the strongest candidate to be the Republican Party’s nominee in the next U.S. presidential election. Despite all the criminal charges against him, he leads in every poll. His prospective re-election must be taken seriously and the reasons why he resonates so strongly with a large portion of the American people should be examined.

Trump-supporting Americans perceive mainstream U.S. and world media coverage of him to be largely unfair. He represents a substantial portion of the country who feel forgotten and ignored and will continue to back him even if they don’t fully understand his own intentions because they sense that he speaks for them. The country’s economic trajectory during his presidency, until the anomalous COVID-19 outbreak, was also very impressive on most counts.

As for the 2020 election, a lot of Trump supporters believe that there were many oddities in its circumstances, even if it was ultimately determined to be valid. Moreover, they question the timing of his current indictments ahead of next year’s election as being politically motivated. This sentiment is confirmed by the fact that the legal charges against him are rallying rather than enervating his support.

Although there may be competent alternative candidates to Trump in the Republican Party, what is it that puts him in the lead despite his many personal flaws? The answer would appear to lie in his bewildering ability to communicate and connect with people, albeit not with everyone. This is why he is so beloved by those who see things his way and also why he is so hated by those who don’t. There is debate among Republicans about whether to nominate a less controversial candidate who advocates similar policies, but so far no one who fits that bill seems to match Trump’s capacity to convert mere policy support into devotion that turns people out to vote en masse. In this respect, he is not unlike Barack Obama as a candidate for the Democrats.

If Trump is once again elected, there will be significant consequences for the world. Many pundits predict that if he returns to power, the U.S. will become more isolationist. However, his supporters argue that his past emphasis on “America First” is misinterpreted, as it does not mean “only America” but rather a prioritization of domestic issues, as any less significant country might pursue. They also emphasize that under his rule the United States would not seek isolationism, but instead attempt to shift the burden of maintaining the international order to be more fairly shared with allies. As to the issue of immigration, the U.S. is a country created by immigration, but they do not want uncontrolled and illegal flows of migrants to be simply acquiesced. They also stress that Trump advocates international free trade, but on fairer terms.

However, as a Korean, these words from Trump's advocates frankly don’t come across as convincing. Many people remember the rude politics of his tenure. Concerns abound that South Korea could in the near future face a very serious security crisis with North Korea, so the prospect of another Trump presidency weighs heavily on South Korean minds. Trump would certainly attempt negotiations with North Korea’s leader, Kim Jong-un. Short of war, the worst-case scenario is that he will make a “deal” with the North without considering South Korea’s position, which would allow the North to merely reduce the number of its nuclear weapons and missiles, thereby recognizing it as a de facto nuclear power. This would be unacceptable from a South Korean standpoint.

But Trump was the first U.S. president to bring a North Korean dictator to the meeting table, without preconditions. And for a period of time, it eased the volatile military tensions that existed on the Korean Peninsula. This ability of Trump is undoubtedly one of his strongest advantages as a politician. However, in a recent interview with NBC, he also described the process of resolving the nuclear issue with North Korea as a “deal” instead of an ongoing dialogue, and did not use the term “denuclearization.” The worry is that his proclivity toward showmanship could override the importance of achieving a lasting solution to the Korean problem.

In this regard, it is noteworthy that in an interview with the New York Times in 2016, Trump displayed an open mindset toward the idea that South Korea and Japan might produce their own nuclear-weapon deterrents, depending on specific circumstances.

Even if the second Trump administration becomes a reality, he could not change the basic structure of the South Korea-U.S. alliance, or the triangular cooperation between South Korea, the U.S. and Japan as per the Camp David Agreements. The same goes for Taiwan. However, U.S. allies would be asked to share defense costs more fairly.

Donald Trump thinks the world’s conflicts can be solved through “deals,” which may not be so far removed from what we traditionally call “diplomacy.” It would seem wise for the Yoon Suk Yeol government to closely study Trump’s characteristics and use them in response to future changes, given that he may return to the White House. It should communicate South Korea’s positions regularly to the Trump camp by contacting influential Republican politicians and expert groups through informal lines, as Japan has done with U.S. leaders discreetly in the past. Binary thinking along the lines of “Trump re-elected: disaster!" or "Trump defeated: we are saved!” is too simplistic and even dangerous. Given his eccentric and unpredictable personality, the growing likelihood of Trump’s return to power could be a challenging crisis for South Korea, but the crisis in nature could be an opportunity at the same time.

 

Park Jung-won (park_jungwon@hotmail.com), Ph.D. in law from the London School of Economics (LSE), is a professor of international law at Dankook University.