my timesThe Korea Times

Tzuyu affair jinxes hallyu

Listen

JYP mishandling reveals problems of cultural phenomenon

By Oh Young-jin

The recent flag controversy involving Tzuyu, a 16-year-old Taiwanese member of multinational K-pop girl group Twice reveals what has gone wrong with the nation’s cultural export drive, branded as hallyu or the Korean wave.

Most conspicuous is the mishandling of the case by JYP, the entertainment agency that represents Twice. JYP together with SM and YG are the country’s top three agencies.

The trio, founded and run by entertainers, has enjoyed about 10 years of explosive growth thanks to the hallyu boom. But their decision-making process has changed little from the early days, when no second opinions were allowed.

That top-down practice appears obvious throughout the latest controversy triggered by footage of Tzuyu waving a Taiwanese flag on MBC’s omnibus interactive program “My Little Television,” inviting an onslaught of nationalistic Chinese netizens.

JYP founder Park Jin-young yielded easily for fear of a backlash against not just his plans to advance Twice into the Chinese market but also his other interests in hallyu’s biggest market. But it was a flawed move. He had Tzuyu appear with little makeup in front of a camera and apologize for waving her country’s flag, telling the Chinese that she supported the “One-China” policy agreed upon by Taiwan and China in 1992 that recognizes their separate existences. Park also apologized.

His actions raised a wrath of anger from the Taiwanese, who felt slighted to see their native daughter deny her own country in public and correctly believed it was JYP that forced her to do so.

Park may claim that it was a natural choice to protect a bigger interest over the smaller one but it also gives a bad name to hallyu as a whole, leading non-Chinese fans to think they may be ditched like the Taiwanese were.

Korean fans have also heaped a great deal of criticism on Park’s ill-considered apologies to the Chinese, taking them as their own personal humiliation. Obviously, it was Park’s snap decision and there is little evidence that says otherwise. If the whole brouhaha had been professionally handled, Park would have taken more time and tried to present a better case to calm the Chinese rather than apologize without being able to state what he did wrong.

Another point of contention is whether he had the authority to force a certain political view on his protege, who is a minor. Choosing a political view is every individual’s right and an indispensable ingredient to democracy. What if Tzuyu had expressed her support for the One-China principle, when she in fact doesn’t support the Communists on the mainland and thereby backs Taiwan’s independence?

This would be tantamount to oppressing her political freedom.

Adding to it is Park’s seniority over Tzuyu and other entertainer-wannabes that gives him the power to make or break their careers on a whim. In other words, the Taiwanese girl couldn’t say no to whatever her master asks of her. For example, Tzuyu had to appear in the taping of MBC’s sports event for young stars Monday even while she was still caught up by the flag kerfuffle. JYP may argue that the event was scheduled in advance so there was no other choice, but it can be an act of exacting forced labor from a minor.

Thus, a new and detailed contract is needed now more than ever, considering that many hallyu entertainers start when they are minors and a prevalent trend in K-pop is to put together multinational acts.

Finally, Park himself is too busy with his own music career, leading a TV audition program and running his big entertainment firm. As a matter of fact, he reportedly staged a great performance Wednesday night. However talented Park may be, it is impossible for him or for anyone to do all his duties. Rather, for hallyu, the time for jacks of all trades is gone. To ensure the Korean wave has a sustainable future, it is high time to adopt a division of labor. The Tzuyu case is an unfortunate event but a learning experience that may benefit us in the long run. Of course, it doesn’t mean that Park will be spared from whatever, legal or not, responsibility he has.

Oh Young-jin is The Korea Times’ chief editorial writer and can be contacted at foolsdie5@ktimes.com. An abbreviated version of this column can be found as the main editorial in printed papers.