Fair grading for non-scheduled admission
.jpg)
By Lee Eung-tae
As the CSAT (College Scholastic Aptitude Test) is just around the corner, many aspiring college students are making last-ditch efforts with their studies. Even more demanding for them in the run up to CSAT is the burden of also preparing for non-scheduled admission.
Given that its purpose is to recruit students of various talents and personalities aside from their academic ability, this nonscheduled admission test must be desirable. As colleges cannot evaluate applicants’ talents and other important features simply through students’ records, these interviews usually account for between 30 to 60 percent of their total test score.
As interview questions vary depending on the major they apply for, students have to prepare proper answers, which is another burden.
Those who apply for the department of elementary education can expect interview questions concerned with the virtues of elementary teaching. Likewise, one of my students who applied for the department of disabled children was asked to discuss the importance of education for the disabled.
However, not all the interview questions seem suitable for someone who has just completed the high school curriculum. A student told me that her interview mirrored a job interview for a major conglomerate. After taking part in a group debate concerning current issues in our society, she was then asked to summarize the argument and present her own opinions in English.
Ostensibly, this interview technique tests interviewee’s critical thinking and English skills. The problem is that our normal high school curriculum does not meet such an advanced level of interview, except for those who attend a few prestigious foreign language schools. This means ordinary students must resort to private education that provides customized lessons, but at a significant cost.
Worse than this is that not all the interview questions seem to require applicants’ cognitive thinking. Some questions provide nothing but small talk that is quite distant from the essence of the major.
I was shocked to hear from a student who had just returned from her interview. She had applied for aviation major at a college with a high level of competition. However, interview questions were not on par with the college’s prestigious reputation. Rather, they were poor beyond description. Standing in the middle of several applicants, she was asked, ``How tall are you? Can you put your knees together?”
Are these suitable interview questions for a college entrance exam? Judging from these questions, physical attraction is deemed to be more important than academic aptitude and personal achievement through various in-school activities and community services. So what is the measuring stick to let students study in college?
Imagine the frustration of students who failed because of their appearance. They may well be left with a bitter attitude and with a misconception that "beauty” is not beauty itself, but the means for success in our society. This belief could lead to many of them seeking plastic surgery as soon as possible.
College is an extension of learning from high school. So, interview questions should be associated with the high school curriculum. Otherwise, what is the point of high school?
Korea is a country of "justice.” Therefore, "fairness” should be a priority above all other elements in any evaluation by higher institutions. If evaluation elements favor a few privileged high school students or those that are physically attractive, who can really trust the non-scheduled college admission test?
The writer is a teacher in Gimhae Girls' High School in South Gyeongsang Province. His email address is eungtae@gmail.com.