Integration in Northeast Asia

By Lakhvinder Singh
Never before in modern history have China, Japan, and Korea been as closely linked economically as they are now. As an indication of their growing economic interaction, Japan has become China's third-largest trading partner.
In 2006, Chinese exports to Japan reached $118.4 billion and imports from Japan were valued at $92.9 billion, taking the total trade between the two countries to $210 billion.
By the end of 2006, Japan had invested more than $58.2 billion in China, making it the second-largest investor there. Similarly, Korean companies have invested more than $36 billion in 44,000 projects in China. In 2006, China became South Korea's largest trading partner, surpassing the United States.
Despite this growing cooperation, there are some serious problems hindering the growth of the integration process in these three countries. Foremost is the issue of North Korea's nuclear program.
Despite the fact that all three countries agree that North Korea's nuclear program poses a serious threat to peace and stability in the region, they fail to agree on a common approach to deal with it.
Each has adopted a separate approach to deal with North Korea based on their national interests and domestic political dynamics. All three countries have adopted policies, which often cut across the purpose of the policies of other countries in the region.
The failure of these countries to produce a joint strategy toward North Korea is emerging as one of the most significant setbacks to the ongoing integration process in the region.
Historical and territorial disputes have also been causing serious friction between the three countries. Issues such as Japan's wartime mobilization of ``comfort women,'' misleading history textbooks, its leaders' Yasukuni Shrine visits, and the issue of chemical weapons in China have caused much mistrust between them.
Due to various domestic political pressures, they are refusing to give in to each other's demands. As a result, narrow nationalism has been growing.
Disputes between Korea and Japan in 2005 and between China and Japan in 2006 reflect the conflict between the regional powers on politics, security and economic competition for natural resources. Each country is currently overstepping its national boundaries to claim natural resources.
Currently, the Northeast Asian Integration Process is becoming more complex by the day. Opposing forces are at work at the same time. Economic forces are bringing the countries of the region together like never before.
However, political forces prevailing in the region have failed in reconciliation and are forcing each other in opposite directions.
Despite the growing economic exchanges, politically, the three countries are not ready yet to take each other on as equal partners. All suspect the others' intentions and are trying to outdo them in the region.
Thus the most important factor that is hindering the growth of regionalism among the three countries is the ``trust factor.'' Korea, Japan and China simply do not trust each other.
If they want to continue on the path of regionalism, they need to go the extra mile to win each others' confidence. Japan, as the largest economy and a history of aggression, has a special role to play in this process.
However, thus far it has failed to fully recognize the benefits of more regionalism in Northeast Asia and has yet to play a more proactive role in promoting mutual trust amongst the three countries.
Japan needs to do more to reduce regional fears. It should promote regional free trade and open its markets, most importantly its agricultural market, to other countries.
On historical issues that have caused so much regional friction, it should adopt a more pragmatic approach and work more proactively to soothe the hurt national pride of Korea and China.
Economic relations between the three countries are growing quickly. However, regional integration cannot be left to only economic components. There is a limit to which economic forces can push the integration process further. Some kind of political understanding between the three players is crucial.
Currently, they share few common political values and beliefs. While Japan and Korea are functioning democracies, China is still (at least politically) a socialist state with few rights afforded to its people.
Common political values such as respect for international law, respect of sovereignty, and a desire for peaceful resolution of conflicts must be shared by all three nations. Without such shared beliefs in basic political values, no amount of economic exchange will work.
Political and economic integration must go side by side. Promoting one at the cost of the other can only have counterproductive results in the long run.
Dr. Lakhvinder Singh, senior research fellow at the Institute for Far Eastern Studies in Seoul, is president of the Indo-Korean Policy Forum. He can be reached at parvkapc@rediffmail.com.