my timesThe Korea Times

Korea urged to cope with demographic challenges

Listen

The Moon Jae-in administration confidently said Dec. 19 that Korea will have a 2.4 percent growth rate in 2020, recovering from the chip industry downturn and boosting exports. However, skepticism has emerged over this rosy outlook, as the country is facing political uncertainties in the short run and an aging population in the long run. Against this backdrop, calls have grown for the government to take proper measures to overcome those challenges and inject new vigor into the economy.

The Korea Times conducted interviews with six global economic experts to ask for their advice for the country to get back to its growth track. They are Natixis Asia-Pacific chief economist Alicia Garcia-Herrero, Wharton School professor Mauro F. Guillen, Loyola Marymount University professor Sohn Sung-won, Moody's Senior Vice President Christian de Guzman, S&P Asia-Pacific economist Vishrut Rana and ING Asia-Pacific chief economist Robert Carnell.

The following discussion has been reconstituted based on separate interviews, which were conducted from Nov. 28 to Dec. 9. ― ED.

By Park Jae-hyuk

Q: What would be the biggest short- and long-term challenges facing the Korean economy?

Alicia Garcia-Herrero: Short-term is the China slowdown followed by the U.S-China trade war and the Korea-Japan trade war. China is still Korea's most important trading partner, and imports from China are collapsing not only because China is decelerating but also because it is moving up the ladder and, thereby, shedding imports of intermediate goods from Korea. Medium-term is aging and the lack of openings to immigration and also competition.

Mauro F. Guillen: Short-term is the trade war, and long-term is population aging.

Sohn Sung-won: Demographics and productivity are the two long-term challenges. In the short run, political uncertainties at home and the trade war between the U.S. and China are key concerns.

Christian de Guzman: We still view demographic change as the biggest structural challenge given the projected impact of aging on growth and fiscal outcomes.

Vishrut Rana: Demographic changes represent a significant structural challenge for the economy.

Q: Could you provide short- and medium-term policy suggestions for President Moon Jae-in and his economic team to inject new vigor into the Korean economy and put its growth back on track?

Garcia-Herrero: More immigration and more openness to foreign competition. Also, extending working life to support the cost of the elderly population.

Guillen: Diversifying exports is very important.

Sohn: In order for consumers and businesses to spend money, uncertainties must decrease. Unfortunately, Korea has many uncertainties, both political and economic emanating from home and abroad. Fiscal policy could be more stimulative, and the Bank of Korea should be more supportive of the economy.

Robert Carnell: Breaking up control by major conglomerates of their suppliers would help foster more competition and innovation, as well as leveling what is currently a two-tier labor system in manufacturing. I think Moon has already started to do that, and the policies now need time to deliver.

Q: Can you identify a few key themes that will rule the global economy and business world in 2020?

Garcia-Herrero: The year 2020 will be the one in which we shall recognize that the world is moving to two ecosystems and that the trade war was the beginning of a profound strategic competition between the U.S. and China. Korea will need to take a position.

Guillen: Trade wars and the U.S. election.

Sohn: The trade war is expanding and will have more negative effects on the Korean economy. Depending on who becomes the next U.S. president, it could have major repercussions on the Korean economy.

Guzman: We see downside risks to the global economy and fiscal finances from uncertainties related to political risk. Another theme, especially among countries with ample fiscal space and unfettered access to funding markets such as Korea, will be fiscal accommodation; already in the past few weeks, we have seen announcements of large budgetary expansions or stimulus packages to help offset downside risks to growth in Asian countries like Japan, Hong Kong and Korea.

Rana: The U.S.-China tensions and monetary policy. As central banks have eased policy, there is less space and fewer tools available in the bag to counter any deterioration in the economic outlook.

Carnell: The absence of any monetary solution to prevailing economic weakness and the increased reliance on fiscal policy.

Q: How do you think the trade feud between the U.S. and China will unfold down the road? Do you see any chance that they will reach a compromise next year or do you expect that the trade feud will drag on for years?

Rana: The tensions between the U.S. and China are more about technology than trade, and the thorniest issues between the two, including market access and level playing fields against domestic competitors, remain unresolved and difficult to tackle. As such, we expect tensions to drag on.

Guillen: There will be a resolution before the election. Trump cannot afford to create a war and then not bring it to a conclusion.

Sohn: Most people say Trump will settle with China before the election. However, there is a good chance that the friction could continue on adversely influencing the global economy including Korea.

Guzman: Notwithstanding the possibility that a first phase of a trade deal will be passed imminently, tensions between the U.S. and China will play out for years, even in the event of a Trump defeat in next year's presidential elections. These tensions have expanded beyond trade and now touch upon a broader range of issues related to broader geostrategic considerations that will not be easily addressed.

Carnell: They will eventually reach a deal, but it won't be a very good one, which might then unravel in 2020, and lead to a re-escalation of the trade war either later that year or in years to come. Essentially, I think it is hard to return to the period before the tariffs were imposed.