my timesThe Korea Times

Korean platform firms could fall victim to new regulations

Listen
Fair Trade Commission Chairman Han Ki-jeong speaks during a briefing on the legislation of a platform regulation here, at Government Complex Seoul, Tuesday. Yonhap

Fair Trade Commission Chairman Han Ki-jeong speaks during a briefing on the legislation of a platform regulation here, at Government Complex Seoul, Tuesday. Yonhap

Naver, Kakao, Coupang vulnerable to reverse discrimination

Naver, Kakao and Coupang – three leading platform firms here – are feared to suffer reverse discrimination from controversial platform regulations being pushed by an antitrust agency, as the move could weaken their business competitiveness against Google and other foreign rivals, industry officials said Wednesday.

The concerns came in response to the Fair Trade Commission's (FTC) latest decision to introduce the regulation targeting what the watchdog calls "de facto monopolistic platform operators."

The FTC plans to enforce its legislation after designating a group of market-dominant companies. Those classified into the group will be subject to the regulation whose details include a ban on any unfair business acts restricting users of a certain platform from using others.

But officials in the IT industry cried foul over what they consider an unfair policy, because foreign platform giants – such as Google – are highly likely to evade the regulatory hurdle again.

“It looks doubtful whether the authority will be able to regulate Korean platform firms and their overseas counterparts on an equal footing,” an official at a local platform company said on condition of anonymity.

“The watchdog is likely to consider a set of standards – such as the number of users or sales volume – for the designation of the list of monopolistic platform companies. But authorities still face a tough time in exactly calculating the sales and revenues of overseas platform firms, including Google. Under the circumstance, Korean companies will be hardest hit by the regulation, which is not fair.”

Another official at a platform firm also raised concerns over the planned introduction of the regulations, saying that they are redundant.

“The watchdog can regulate platform firms under the current legal system, but pushes ahead with another regulation, which may hamper the potential growth and innovation of local firms amid their intensifying rivalry with foreign competitors,” the official said.

An office building of Naver, the nation's dominant portal operator, in Bundang, Gyeonggi Province / Yonhap

An office building of Naver, the nation's dominant portal operator, in Bundang, Gyeonggi Province / Yonhap

But the FTC appears set in pushing ahead with the legislation, arguing that the move will generate preventive effects against any possible undue business activities by platform firms.

“The watchdog has reacted to any unfair practices by monopolistic platform firms, but the pace of our countermeasures was too slow to block the monopolistic acts and help build a fair competition ecosystem here,” an official from the FTC said.

The authority expected the legislation of the regulation to boost fair competition in the market, thereby reducing the financial burden on small business owners and customers.

“The regulation is expected to reinforce innovation and competition in the platform industry by enabling more startups to make their entry into the market,” the FTC official added.

Kwon Sae-hwa, head of internet policy division at K-Internet, said the organization will come up with countermeasures against the regulatory move. K-Internet is an association representing a group of the aforementioned local platform giants.

“We are reviewing measures on how to minimize the potential repercussions of the regulation,” he said. “For now, Korean companies will be a major target, considering that the FTC and other authorities have virtually failed to regulate overseas platform giants for the past few years due to a legal grey area. This will be the same case for the latest regulation.”

Spokespeople from Naver, Kakao and Coupang declined to comment in detail, citing the sensitivity of the issue.

An association representing local internet firms expressed strong opposition to the planned legislation.

“As was shown by AliExpress’ rapid rise to become the No. 2 e-commerce platform in Korea, the digital market is open to free competition without entry barriers,” the Digital Economy Confederation said in a statement shortly after the FTC’s announcement. The regulation will result in customers and small business owners incurring damage without generating any positive impact on the industry, according to the confederation.