my timesThe Korea Times

'Overhaul regulations': Foreign investors raise collective voice against Korea

Listen

American Chamber of Commerce in Korea (AMCHAM) Chairman James Kim, center, moderates a panel discussion between leaders of four other foreign commerce chambers in Korea, at a seminar at the Grand Hyatt Hotel Seoul, Friday. From left are British Chamber of Commerce in Korea CEO Sean Blakeley, European Chamber of Commerce in Korea President Christoph Heider, Kim, French Chamber of Commerce in Korea Chairman David-Pierre Jalicon and Korean-German Chamber of Commerce CEO Barbara Zollmann. / Yonhap

By Nam Hyun-woo

Five foreign chambers of commerce in Korea expressed concerns about the Moon Jae-in government's regulatory environment Friday, saying it needs to be more predictable and consistent.

The chambers of the United States, Britain, the European Union, France and Germany held a seminar and adopted a joint statement. This is the first time the chambers have held a joint event and expressed their shared worries about the country's regulations.

In the statement, the chambers stressed the government needs to “give greater weight to the predictability and consistency of regulatory environment” and “improve coordination between all government agencies to ensure consistent and predictable enforcement of rules and regulations.”

It continued that the government's announcement to potentially eliminate the flat tax benefit for foreign residents who have been in Korea for more than five years will create “economic disincentives for foreign companies, triggering relocations and involuntary repatriation of employees to lower-cost jurisdictions.”

“We believe it is beneficial for the economy to continue the flat rate even for those who have been in Korea for more than five years,” the statement read.

The chambers also expressed worries on the lowering of the reporting threshold for foreign financial assets and the penalty for failing to make the report or delayed reporting, saying they are unique and end up forcing expats to leave the country.

Though the American Chamber of Commerce in Korea (AMCHAM) Chairman James Kim stressed that the event was not aimed at raising complaints against the government, participants said the administration should understand that the chambers share the same goal of building a Korean economy that is strong, transparent and innovative, and policies in various fields should better comply with international standards.

Greg Briscoe, the U.S. Senior Commercial Officer in Seoul, said despite the Korea-U.S. free trade agreement's contribution to investment and innovation, there is still a long way to go in their mutual trade, citing “non-tariff barriers, regulations and market accessibility” as key areas that should be improved.

European Chamber of Commerce in Korea President Christoph Heider said Korea should advance into overseas markets to achieve 2 to 3 percent economic growth, and this requires more small and medium enterprises to learn international standards.

French Chamber of Commerce in Korea Chairman David-Pierre Jalicon said foreign firms in Korea are also members of the Korean economy and should be treated as “those who are on the same boat.”

“When we look at renewable energy, internet of things and other Fourth Industrial Revolution issues, a country cannot handle them alone and cooperation between many countries is required. Unless there is an international standard, countries cannot cooperate,” Jalicon said.

During a panel discussion session, AMCHAM Blockchain Committee Co-Chair Joung Ji-won said her own business had to setup headquarters in Hong Kong due to Korea's regulations, and the government should make its fintech regulations more predictable.

“What is worse than a bad regulation is ambiguous regulation,” Joung said. “It is regrettable that a business' success or failure hinges on the regulation, not on the quality of its service.”

The seminar was held at the Grand Hyatt Seoul Hotel and 150 business chamber officials, government officials and international firm CEOs attended.