Hyundai E&C slammed for 'backpedaling' on coal exit

Korean builder to push for controversial coal power plant project in Vietnam
By Kim Hyun-bin
Hyundai Engineering & Construction (E&C), one of Korea's major construction companies, has been under growing criticism for “backpedaling” on the global campaign to phase out coal, as it is pushing ahead with a controversial coal-fired power plant project in Vietnam.
The company has been hit with massive protests from both international and domestic environmental groups after winning a contract worth 948 billion won ($800 million) in mid-June to build the 1,200MW coal-fired power plant in Huyen Quang Trach County in Quang Binh Province in central Vietnam.
One MW is equal to one million watts or one thousand kilowatts. According to the U.S. National Hydropower Association, 1MW can power 750 to 1,000 homes. This means 1,200 MW should be able to power nearly one million homes.
Despite the environmental groups urging the Korean builder to withdraw, the company said it has no plans to drop the project, adding that it has been preplanned for years.
“The coal-fired power plant project was a 10-year-long Vietnamese government project. We do not have any other plans to construct additional fossil fuel plants after this, but we will go ahead with the ongoing project as planned,” a Hyundai E&C official said.

Hyundai E&C CEO Yoon Young-jun
Hyundai's decision to push ahead with the project not only contradicts the company's avowed environmental, social and corporate governance (ESG) principles, but also goes against worldwide efforts to end the use of coal for power.
Under the COP26 agreement reached in early November in Glasgow, Scotland, around 190 nations and organizations pledged to join the movement to phase out coal-fueled power generation and stop building new plants.
“Hyundai's move comes as a direct contradiction to the company's ESG initiatives as well as the global trend toward going coal-free to better tackle climate change,” Kwon Woo-hyun, the climate and energy coordinator at the Korea Federation for Environmental Movements, told The Korea Times.
He pointed out that the company secured the power plant project while public financial institutions and other Korean conglomerates were declaring a halt to overseas investments in these, after the Korean government and companies received international criticism for their investment in coal-fired power plants in Indonesia and Vietnam a year ago.
“But Hyundai E&C pushed forward with the Quang Trach 1 project, which has raised risks associated with ethical management,” Kwon said, adding that such plants have already created problems for the company as its Cirebon plant in Indonesia has been receiving much criticism.
Contradicting principles, strategies
Youn Se-jong, climate finance program director at the Seoul-based non-profit Solutions for Our Climate (SFOC), echoed that view. “Hyundai E&C's apparent plans to build one final coal plant calls into question the sincerity of the company's declaration of a coal exit, and contradicts its attempts to build a reputation as a forward-thinking and sustainable company,” he said.
“In the face of growing concern over climate change, investors and customers will no doubt be shocked that Hyundai decided to still take a financial and reputational gamble,”?he added. “Continuing the Quang Trach 1 project will tarnish the reputation of not just Hyundai E&C but also its parent Hyundai Motor Group. It will also affect Korea's efforts to exit coal.”
Earlier this year, Hyundai E&C heavily promoted its inclusion in the “2020 CDP Korea Hall of Fame” announced by the Carbon Disclosure Project (CDP) Korean Committee.
“The company has been recognized to be the best in the world for its response to climate change,” Hyundai E&C said at that time.
It also launched the Sustainability Management Council in October last year announcing new policies to respond to climate change.
Some civic activists said that Hyundai E&C is promoting its response to climate change on the surface but behind the scenes has been preparing to expand its coal-fueled power plant business.
“Declaring that it will stop building overseas coal plants in the future is somewhat deceptive because there are no more coal projects to be procured. If it is serious about the coal phase-out, Hyundai E&C needs to find a way to withdraw its funding and involvement in the project in Vietnam,” Kwon said.
When Hyundai E&C won the controversial Vietnam project in June, Beyond Coal, a local coal-free civic group, sent a letter to company CEO Yoon Young-jun raising concerns about its participation.
The civic group emphasized that investments in coal projects were not financially justifiable and there was a high risk of a negative environmental impact.
"The fact that the company won an order to construct a coal plant, which is pointed out as the biggest threat in responding to climate change, will inevitably reduce the authenticity and credibility of the company's ESG management policy," Beyond Coal said, separately.
Another problem is Vietnam's air pollutant emission standards which are much lower than Korea's. “Already there is serious environmental damage to nearby residents from coal plants, which emit a lot of nitrogen oxides, sulfur oxides and fine dust," the group said.

Market Forces' full-page ad published in the British Financial Times in opposition to Hyundai E&C's Vietnamese coal power plant. Courtesy of Climate Media Hub
In July, a full-page ad designed by the Australian environmental group Market Forces and showing Hyundai Motor's flagship EV IONIQ was published in the Financial Times in the U.K. The content shows an electric vehicle being charged with electricity produced by a coal-fired power plant. The ad contains a message saying that Hyundai E&C should not participate in the construction of the project in Vietnam.

Hyundai E&C headquarters in Seoul / Korea Times file
Earlier this year, Hyundai E&C was also involved in a corruption scandal related to the construction of the Cirebon Unit 2 project in Indonesia in 2019, as it was accused of bribing a local county governor to facilitate the project. Due to the controversial coal investments and corruption scandal, Norges Bank, the central bank of Norway, placed the Korean firm as a target of observation for the next four years, claiming the company was "responsible for grave corruption."
“We did not bribe the local county governor; it was our Indonesian agency that offered the bribe and has been under investigation. We do not have the details of the ongoing investigation. Also there will be no repercussions against Hyundai E&C regarding the issue,” another Hyundai E&C official said.