my timesThe Korea Times
  1. Opinion
  2. Editorial

ED Other options

Listen
  • Published Jul 6, 2017 4:46 pm KST
  • Updated Jul 6, 2017 4:46 pm KST

If sanctions don’t work, what’s next?

North Korea dares the world to do what little it can do after its allegedly successful test of an intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM) Tuesday. The world is at a loss and divided. South Korea and the United States are pushing for a stronger dose of sanctions _ possibly a secondary boycott aimed at cutting off its cash flow _ while China and Russia are calling for restraint by all nations.

It doesn’t need much clairvoyance to know what will happen next. There will be some more bickering among the nations concerned at the United Nations; they will agree to some toothless additional punitive actions and then go back to business pretty much as usual.

Seoul, Washington, Beijing, Moscow and Tokyo all know that they are stymied by the lack of good options, being left with extreme choices such as a preemptive strike at the risk of a full-fledged war.

If there is currently no way of interrupting this ongoing vicious cycle, now is the time to think ahead and plan what to do to prevent the North from further upping the ante.

It should be started with the admission that pressuring China to do more on the North is not working as well as believed, whether it is due to Beijing’s sleight of hand or an actual loss of influence on Pyongyang.

China, the only benefactor of the thug state, can cut off its oil supply to the North and force it to surrender or so we think. But Beijing has too much at stake if Pyongyang unravels _ a massive refugee influx and chaos near its industrial center in the northeastern part of China. It would not be the only victim, if this nightmare scenario comes to pass. Seoul would be affected as well and so would the U.S.

Then what would be the alternative to solve this dilemma, which is not as disastrous as the use of force but still encourages China to work harder, if it has failed to try as hard as it can?

A clue can be found in the joint statement issued by the foreign ministries of China and Russia after the North’s latest missile test. In it, a roadmap for the resolution of the North’s nuclear and missile challenges is provided. The gist is to have the U.S. and South Korea halt their joint military exercises in return for the North’s freeze of its weapons of mass destruction programs. The next step is to set up comprehensive principles on the renunciation of the use of force, nonaggression and peaceful coexistence. Finally, a peace regime for the Korean Peninsula and Northeast Asia must be established along with the normalization of U.S.-North Korea relations.

The spirit and substance of this joint proposition reflects what China has called for, suggesting simultaneous dialogue for denuclearization and peace talks.

The reason that this proposal has been on the table without being taken up are suspicions about China’s motivation _ using it to send the American military packing and dominate the peninsula and the region. Now, we are being forced to choose between a nuclear-armed and ICBM-touting young dictator, the military option and China’s suspected good offices. The least of the three evils is becoming clearer.