my timesThe Korea Times

'Obama won't back Apple again'

Listen

By Kim Yoo-chul

Albert Foer

U.S. President Barack Obama will not be able to back Apple again in its patent dispute with Samsung, according to the president of the American Antitrust Institute (AAI).

This implies that Samsung may be in a better position going into its second patent battle in a San Jose court.

Last year, Obama rejected U.S. International Trade Commission’s (USITC) findings that Apple had infringed on some of Samsung’s “standard essential patents (SEPs),” dealing a major blow to the Korean technology giant.

This time, however, the main issues of contention will be related to “commercial patents,” not SEPs, according to Samsung.

“The Obama administration has no policy basis for vetoing an exclusion order flowing from infringement of a non-SEP,” AAI President Albert Foer said said in an interview.

The two firms will meet again on March 31 in the same U.S. court to argue their cases before a new jury.

Samsung was ordered to pay 1 trillion won to Apple as presiding Judge Lucy Koh ruled in favor of the latter on SEPs based on the “fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory (FRAND) principle.”

“The SEPs and commercial patents are different issues,” Foer said.

Obama was able to veto the previous USITC rulings because they were related to SEPs, which everyone in the industry can collectively use.

However, any rulings on commercial patents cannot be overturned, Foer said.

Samsung claims Apple has used its commercial patents without paying proper royalties.

As the upcoming battle will address claims by each side over patent infringement of devices such as the Samsung Galaxy S3 and Apple iPhone5, Samsung believes this round will be more significant than the first.

“The fresh battle would be about a fact question not a policy question,” said the AAI president. He didn’t directly mention that the second battle will be favorable for Samsung, saying he has no intention of attacking the U.S. administration.

On a related note, citing the latest decision by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) that nullifies Apple’s ‘915’ pinch-to-zoom patent, German-based patent expert Florian Mueller said it wouldn’t be fair to enforce an injunction over it.

Samsung uses Google’s Android operating system, but Apple has not yet sued Google directly.

But officials said Google executives may appear in court because the second court case is expected to boost the “Google-Samsung alliance” thanks to the dispute’s coverage of non-SEPs and commercial patents, according to officials at the Korea Intellectual Property Office.

“Unlike SEPs, commercial patents are proprietary and the results of huge investment. They are also not-committed to any industry standards as commercial patents are legitimate ways for firms to differentiate their products,” said a Samsung official, asking not to be named. “Because the latest Samsung and Apple devices support high-end functions, Apple can’t produce its iPads and iPhones without Samsung’s commercial patents.”

Foer urged the two companies to resolve all their outstanding issues through arbitration.

“The mutually assured destruction and scorched earth commitment of both parties is monumentally wasteful and disserves the public generally. They can then direct all of their future litigation savings into more investment in innovative competition,” Foer advised.