alt
2012-06-27 16:36

Apple wins ruling for Tab sale ban


By Kim Yoo-chul

A U.S. judge ordered Samsung to stop selling its Galaxy 10.1 tablet computer in America Wednesday (KST), issuing a preliminary injunction in a ruling on Apple’s patent lawsuit.

The ruling came a week after the Korean firm won a ruling for the first time against Apple in the Netherlands.

Judge Lucy H. Koh of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, San Jose Division ordered Samsung to temporarily halt sales of its tablets in the United States because it illegally copied the design of the popular iPad.

The ruling will take effect after Apple posts a bond of $2.6 million toward any damages sustained by Samsung, according to officials.

``Although Samsung will necessarily be harmed by being forced to withdraw its product from the market before the merits can be determined after a full trial, the harm faced by Apple absent an injunction on the Galaxy Tab 10.1 is greater,’’ the judge said in an eight-page ruling.

Koh, who previously denied Apple's bid for an injunction on the tablet and multiple Galaxy smartphones, said Apple had presented a strong case.

Samsung downplayed the impact of the latest ``unfavorable ruling’’ in the United States, saying that it will be limited and short-lived.

``We are sorry about the ruling. But we strongly believe the impact of the ruling will be limited and short-lived because Samsung is already securing product variants,’’ it said in a statement.

``Apple sought a preliminary injunction against Samsung’s Galaxy Tab 10.1, based on a single design patent that addressed just one aspect of the product's overall design,’’ Samsung added.

``Should Apple continue to make legal claims based on such a generic design patent, design innovation and progress in the industry could be restricted,’’ it said.

Samsung Electronics has previously released a modified version of the Galaxy Tab 10.1 called Galaxy 10.1N in Germany after the original tablet was banned in Germany. In Australia, Samsung has also been selling changed version of its tablets after a similar ruling.

Samsung has been releasing tablets with screen sizes of 7 inches, 7.7 inches, 8.9 inches and 10.1 inches in an attempt to narrow the market gap with the sector leader Apple.

Attention is being shifted to whether the ruling will give Apple the upper hand in negotiations with Samsung in upcoming cross-licensing deals, though officials from both companies remained silent on the matter.

The ruling is expected to force Samsung lawyers to prepare highly fine-tuned strategies in their battle with Apple as this is the first time a U.S. court has accepted a request by the latter, officials and patent experts based in Seoul told The Korea Times.

Apple initially brought Samsung to court two years ago as part of an apparent plan to restrict the growth of Google, which has the world’s best-selling mobile operating system ― Android.

``Even though the ruling was a preliminary injunction, it will be a reference in the upcoming trial,’’ said one legal expert by telephone.

Samsung and Apple are waiting for a trial which has been set for July 30 after chief executives from both companies failed to reach a settlement.

In a separate case, Apple recently hired a former Samsung legal chief. Kim & Chang represent the firm here.

To squeeze Samsung, Morrison & Forester and Wilmer Hale, Apple’s two leading litigation law firms, have recently hired 73 Korean-American lawyers and additional document reviewers, German-based patent expert Florian Mueller reported on the FossPatents blog.




관련 한글기사


삼성 갤럭시탭 10.1 美시판 중단 판결

미국 캘리포니아 북부 연방지방법원은 삼성전자 갤럭시탭 10.1 모델의 미국 내 판매를 금지해달라는 애플사의 가처분 신청을 26일(현지시간) 받아들였다.

이에 따라 해당 제품의 미국 내 시판은 즉각 중단될 것으로 보인다.

담당 판사 루시 고는 "이 사건에서 본안소송 재판을 거쳐 삼성의 이득 규모가 확정되기 이전에 제품 판매가 중단돼 삼성이 불가피하게 손해를 입게 된다 하더라도, 갤럭시탭 10.1에 대한 판금 가처분 조치가 없을 경우 애플이 입을 손해가 더 크다"고 결정문에서 밝혔다.

또 "삼성이 경쟁할 권리를 갖고 있으나 (타사의 지적재산권을) 침해하는 제품을 시장에 쏟아냄으로써 부당하게 경쟁할 권리는 없다"고 덧붙였다.

고 판사는 작년 12월 삼성 갤럭시 스마트폰과 갤럭시탭에 대한 애플의 판매금지 가처분 신청 사건에서 삼성 측의 손을 들어준 바 있다.

그러나 이후 연방항소법원에서 갤럭시탭 10.1 관련 소송에서 애플이 승소 가능성이 있다고 판결함에 따라 이번 결정을 내렸다.

이번 결정으로 삼성은 미국 내 태블릿PC 시장을 둘러싼 애플과의 분쟁에서 상당한 타격을 입게 됐다. (연합뉴스)


  • 1. Ghost camera captures underage sex
  • 2. Army deploys Surion copters
  • 3. West Point staff member accused of spying on female cadets
  • 4. NK envoy's meeting with Xi Jinping becomes center of attention
  • 5. NK special envoy in Beijing
  • 6. Man in love with military career
  • 7. Female body found in singer's car; suicide suspected
  • 8. 6-year-old girl crushed to death by suicidal man
  • 9. Two men cleared of spy charges decades after guilty verdict
  • 10. Fancy a burn-up? £200,000 supercar goes up in flames


Copyeditors, cartoonist wanted
‘Expat citizen reporters’ wanted
Koreatimes.co.kr puts on a new dress