The society that asks how old you are
By Oh Kong-dan
As I have remarked in these pages, I am proud of how much my native country has changed for the better.
Koreans are smarter, healthier, richer, and more globalized now than when I was growing up in a somewhat stifling traditional society. Even the traditional discrimination against women are falling by the wayside. But how about Koreans’ rigid views about age?
Some years ago Korean seniors were outraged when a political party leader declared that people older than 70 should stay home and not vote in the forthcoming presidential election because they were too old to make good decisions. Now if an American politician said something like that, millions of senior voters would rise up and denounce him, and the powerful lobbying group, AARP (formerly the American Association of Retired Persons, with a membership of about 40 million) would probably make his political life very difficult.
Many Asian scholars and officials that I meet in my work are interested to learn about the retirement age in America. Japanese and Koreans in particular are prone to raise the question, ``Do you have a retirement age at the think tank where you work?” Perhaps I should take this question as an indication that I am getting on in years. My answer is ``I’m not aware of any retirement age.” When I ask in turn, ``Is there a retirement age at the organization where you work?” the answer is usually, ``Oh, yes, we have strict rules. As a matter of fact this is my last year. I’ll be 60 this June.” And I say, ``Wow, you’re younger than I am, and I’m not even thinking of retiring.”
Now it is true that in the United States some government organizations like the Foreign Service and the military have retirement guidelines. Most military officers retire before 65. Sometimes they want to because they can draw a full pension and go on to second and even third careers in the private sector. Other employees in these government organizations are forced to retire because they reach ``time-in-grade limits”; that is, they fail to receive a promotion in a given time and must move out so that others who are considered more qualified can move up the promotion ladder. In this ``up-or-out” system, they are forced out not because of their age but because they are considered to be less qualified than those of a similar age whom they are competing with.
Those who choose to retire from government service are often well positioned to get a similar but better paying job in the private sector because their personal connections will help the companies they join do business with the government. I have numerous able colleagues who are in their third career: first they were military officers, then they retired to do military-related work for a large profit-making company, and then they moved to a research organization where they could use their life-long experience to address national and global problems.
I’m sure this happens in Korea as well, but I also know of many Korean civil servants and military officers who are forced by their age to retire and then sit around at home, treated like cold rice by their family. This is a great loss to them, and a great loss to society.
As a practical matter, Korea needs to employ its qualified senior citizens, given the low Korean birthrate. From a theoretical viewpoint, a person’s age tells us little about his or her ability to make valuable contributions.
Age, like time-keeping, is simply a convenient construct we use to organize our lives. Time and age do not change anything. Things that happen in time or that happen as one ages are all that matter. Very young people can make great contributions; consider the early careers of young mathematicians and composers and chess players. And very old people can make great contributions.
Grandma Moses, the great American folk artist, didn’t take up painting until she was 76, and she kept on painting until just a few months before she died at the age of 101. Thank goodness no one told her she was too old to paint!
Oh Kong-dan is a research fellow at the Brookings Institution in Washington. She is an expert on Asian affairs. Her recent publications include the report, ``Moving the U.S.-ROK Alliance into the 21st Century" and the book ``The Hidden People of North Korea: Everyday Life in the Hermit Kingdom." She can be reached at kohassig@ida.org.