Opinion
 
    
  
+Login    +Register    +Find Id / Pw 음성듣기 설치 및 이용방법    Home  l  Archives  l  Learning Times  |  Sitemap  |  Subscription  l  Media Kit  l  PDF
   Home > Newszone > Opinion > Times Forum > Saturday, November 21, 2009 | 11:48 a.m. ET
  Nation
  Biz/Finance
  Technology
  Arts & Living
  Sports
  Opinion
    Editorial  
    Thoughts of the Times  
    Today`s Column  
    Desk Column  
    Letter to the Editor  
    The Dawn of Modern Korea  
    Another Korea  
    What`s Your Take?  
    Letter from America  
    Random Walk  
    Sean Hayes  
    Michael Breen  
    Views From Overseas  
    Jon Huer  
    Tom Plate  
    Living Science  
    Pacific Perspective  
    Guest Column  
    Times Forum  
    Readers` Forum  
    Cartoon  
    Great and Simple Things  
    Back Home  
    Ideas & Ideals  
    Jim Hoagland  
    Choi Yearn-hong  
    Today in History  
    Reporter's Notebook  
    Washington Lounge  
    Hyon O'Brien  
  Community
  Special
     
  The Learning Times
     Editorial Listening
     Phone English
     Dear Abby
     Domestic News
     Foreign News
     Screen English
     Live English in Drama
     Discovery Education  
     Ancient Idiom  
     iBT Writing  
     English Writing I
     English Writing II  
     English Grammar
     Grasping Vocab
     iBT Vocab
     Korean Language  
     
     Junior Writing
     Junior Reading
     Junior Reporter
     
 
   05-14-2009 15:50
Illegality of Annexation Treaty


World War II veterans who survived the attack on Pearl Harbor by imperial Japanese forces salute on the deck of the battleship USS Missouri in the naval port in Hawaii, in October 2003, in this file photo. / AP-Yonhap

By Choi Deok-kyoo

Scholars of South Korea, Japan and the United States held an international symposium in Honolulu, Hawaii, from April 23 to 24, to bring new light to Japan's 1910-45 colonial rule of the Korean Peninsula.

The Northeast Asian History Foundation of South Korea and University of Hawaii's School of Pacific and Asian Studies co-organized the event under the title ``Personalities and Politics in Japan's Annexation of Korea.''

The symposium drew attention as the participants reached a consensus that the annexation issue should be illuminated from a global perspective. They acknowledged that research on the topic has so far been made only in the context of the history of two nations ― Korea and Japan.

They also shared a view that it is necessary to expand the horizons of the studies. In the case where the annexation is seen only as matter of the two Asian countries, this may justify the former imperial power's colonization of Korea. At the time of annexation, Japan was a country that had become powerful since the Meiji Restoration, while Korea was a small, weak nation.

To repudiate such a justification, Korean scholars re-evaluated King Gojong, the last monarch of the Joseon Kingdom, as a ruler who sought to modernize the nation. They stressed that the kingdom, once called the ``Korean Empire,'' was an independent state.

The scholars succeeded in revealing that Japan coerced Korea to sign two treaties that led to the colonization of the latter, pointing out that they were illegal. By using threats and intimidation, the island nation concluded the Japan-Korea Protocol in 1905 and the Japan-Korea Annexation Treaty in 1910.

Considering that we now live in an era of globalization, it is high time for us to develop a new method of research to help not only Koreans but also people around the world to recognize the illegal aspects of the treaties.

This method should be objective and go beyond the existing paradigm of research. As such, it is necessary to take a new approach to dealing with the annexation issue from a global perspective by breaking out of the narrow boundaries of individual states or the regional framework of Northeast Asia.

We are now living in a global village where we can look at things and grasp phenomena through images sent by communication satellites. Thus, a ``global history'' approach will be one of the most efficient research methods to enable people the world over to acknowledge the illegality of Japan's annexation of Korea.

During the imperialist era, Japan was a strong nation that occupied and ruled its neighbors in Northeast Asia. But Japan's power could still not match that of the United States and European countries. Besides, Japan was usually subject to intervention and containment by the Western powers which collaborated in blocking the Asian empire's expansion.

Russia, France and Germany entered into an agreement in 1895 in which they intervened in forcing Japan to return Liaodong Peninsula to China. In the end, Japan yielded to the triple intervention and gave up the peninsular, which was ceded to Tokyo following the 1894-95 Sino-Japanese War. The second triple intervention came in 1908 when Germany, the U.S. and China tried to keep Japan in check after its victory in a war with Russia.

Especially, the U.S. administration of then-President William Howard Taft, which was installed in March 1909, adopted a strong containment policy toward Japan. It appointed H. Wilson, who harbored anti-Japanese sentiment, as deputy secretary of state, to effectively put the brakes on Japan's territorial ambitions.

As a result, Japan's pace of march toward China had to be slowed due to interventions and restraints by the U.S. and other Western countries. In particular, America's open door policy and its efforts to help China preserve its territories were found effective to contain Japan.

These U.S. moves ran counter to Japan's ambition to make inroads into China after the imperialist island nation made Korea and south Manchuria its colonies in the wake of its win in the 1904-05 Russo-Japanese War.

In the end, Japan was forced to make a choice: to give up its vested interests in Korea and south Manchuria, or strengthen its foothold in the region to advance further into China. Regrettably, Japan chose the belligerent course that paved the way for a war against the U.S. instead of taking the road to peace.

For the buildup of its naval force, Japan began work to expand its port facilities in Jinhae, southern Korea, in February 1910, six months before its annexation of the peninsula. Japan also struck a secret deal with Russia in July that year, under which the former acknowledged the latter's sway over Mongolia in exchange for Korea. Japan did all these things to choose war over peace.

After participating in the two-day symposium, I visited USS Arizona Memorial, the resting place of 1,102 of the 1,177 sailors killed on the U.S. warship during the attack on Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941, by Japanese forces.

Upon leaving the memorial site, it struck me that Japan's imperialism and militarism started with the annexation of Korea and ended up in a war with America.

Choi Deok-kyoo is a researcher at the Northeast Asian History Foundation (www.historyfoundation.or.kr) in Seoul. He specialized in modern Korea-Russia foreign relations. He is specially interested in global history.

Reader’s Comments
Notice From KT Website Manager
Bad language will not be tolerated. All comments considered discriminatory against race or sex, or which are considered offensive against certain people, will be eliminated by the manager. Violators will be deprived of their membership.
Please stay on topic.
Gillian   (125.136.135.160)   05-15-2009 14:36
And why no mention of the Anglo-Japanese Alliance of 1902? Japan and England were the two most powerful countries in the world at that time. One would THINK that THIS information would be in Korean history books....
Gillian   (125.136.135.160)   05-15-2009 14:34
Too bad this information isn't in public school history books. My students maintain up and down that the US "Gave" Korea to Japan. No amount of logic can sway them. It really would be nice if a gobal history was taught in public schools....
YCee   (98.210.21.250)   05-14-2009 22:55
Do more research. The text does not match the title. Why no contact email address?
wootaejun   (125.129.158.63)   05-14-2009 17:26
"Upon leaving the memorial site, it struck me that Japan's imperialism and militarism started with the annexation of Korea and ended up in a war with America."----Wow, the author is just realizing this?!?!?!?!
Managerial regulations
◀ Back ▲Top