• Site Map
  • PDF
  • Subscription
  • Register
  • LogIn
  • Site Map
  • PDF
  • Subscription
  • Register
  • LogIn
National
  • Politics
  • Foreign Affairs
  • Defense Affairs
  • Labor & environment
  • Investigations
  • Seoul & provinces
  • Diseases & welfare
  • Foreign Communities
  • Easy Korean
  • Embassy News
  • Education
  • Obituaries
  • Photo News
Sun, February 17, 2019 | 00:40
      • North Korea
      • Entertainment
        • Hallyu
        • Music
        • Dramas & TV shows
        • Movies
        • Performances
        • Exhibitions
      • Opinion
        • Editorial
        • Columnists
          • Park Moo-jong
          • Choi Sung-jin
          • Mark Peterson
          • Troy Stangarone
          • Tong Kim
          • Lee Seong-hyon
          • Andrew Salmon
          • John Burton
          • Jason Lim
          • Donald Kirk
          • Kim Ji-myung
          • Michael Breen
          • Hyon O'Brien
          • Younghoy Kim Kimaro
          • Deauwand Myers
          • Bernard Rowan
          • Casey Lartigue, Jr.
          • Stephen Costello
          • Semoon Chang
          • Korean Historical Sense
        • Reporter's Notebook
        • Blogs
        • Guest Column
        • Thoughts of the Times
        • Letter to the Editor
        • Times Forum
        • Cartoon
        • Today in History
      • Economy
        • Policies
        • Finance
        • Photo News
      • Biz & Tech
        • Automotive
        • IT
        • Game
        • Heavy industries
        • Light industries
        • Science
        • Photo News
      • National
        • Politics
        • Foreign Affairs
        • Defense Affairs
        • Labor & environment
        • Investigations
        • Seoul & provinces
        • Diseases & welfare
        • Foreign Communities
        • Easy Korean
        • Embassy News
        • Education
        • Obituaries
        • Photo News
      • Culture
        • Books
        • Hotel & Travel
        • Fashion
        • Food
        • Fortune Telling
        • Religions
        • Korean Traditions
        • Trend
        • Healthcare
      • Sports
        • Football
        • Golf
        • Baseball
        • Other Sports
      • World
        • Asia Pacific
        • Americas
        • Other Regions
        • SCMP
      • Video
        • News
        • Feature
        • On the spot
      • Photos
      • Community
        • Time Forum
        • Market Place
        • Study Plaza
        • Talk Box
      • Learning English
    Conscientious objectors cautiously hopeful about future
    Posted : 2016-08-17 17:25
    Updated : 2016-08-17 17:49
    Court rulings turning to support alternative service

    By Kim Se-jeong


    An Jung-hyun, 23, is a Jehovah's Witness on trial for refusing to fulfill his compulsory military service. He was found guilty twice in lower courts, and appealed to the Supreme Court in July. Lawyers told him his chances of winning were low given the highest court's precedents, but he is cautiously hopeful.

    This year alone, district courts acquitted nine fellow Jehovah's Witnesses of violations of the Military Law. The most recent ruling came one week ago from the Cheongju District Court which stated, "There are many ways to contribute to the nation without violating a person's basic rights such as social service or alternate work. It is unjust to punish military objectors by criminal law without even making efforts to provide alternatives."

    Another hopeful sign comes from Kim Jae-hyung, a Supreme Court justice nominee who recently expressed his support for such objectors and alternative ways to serve the country. His confirmation hearing will begin in September, and if confirmed, he is expected to add a different opinion on the 13-justice court.

    Ahn Se-young from Amnesty International Korea also showed cautious optimism.

    "These developments certainly reflect growing public support for conscientious objectors," Ahn said.

    While the government has claimed that conscientious objectors do not enjoy public support, Amnesty International Korea and Gallup recently conducted a survey in which more than 70 percent of respondents expressed support for conscientious objectors, according to Ahn.

    "But, the appeals court and highest court are still conservative," Ahn said. She also doubts Kim will be influential enough to change the opinion of the entire top court.

    Kim Dong-in, another Jehovah's Witness, claimed it's time for the Korean government to take a stance.

    "If you look at the world, fewer countries refuse to recognize conscious objectors. It will eventually happen in Korea. It's time for Korea to voluntarily recognize them instead of being coerced to do so under pressure," he said.

    But those against conscientious objectors claim if they are recognized, many people will abuse the system. "If Jehovah's Witnesses are found not guilty and are allowed alternative services, many young men will join the religious group only to avoid military duty," a blogger said. "There will be no way to sort out whether they are really believers or just misusing the system."

    Now, eyes are on the Constitutional Court, which is expected to rule on an appeal by a conscientious objector later this year. Two previous rulings found it unconstitutional to skip military service because of personal beliefs.

    Between 1950 and 2011, more than 16,000 conscientious objectors have been imprisoned in Korea, according to Amnesty International Korea. Every year, hundreds of objectors, mostly Jehovah's Witnesses, are put on trial for their rejection of military service based on their beliefs. Those convicted are sentenced to imprisonment for up to 18 months.

    "There will be so much I won't be able to do if I have a criminal record," An said. "I am not saying that I will avoid my service to the country altogether. I would like to serve my country, but in a different form."

    skim@ktimes.com More articles by this reporter



     
    • Trump says he just doesn't want NK to test nukes, missiles
    • Success on the Rocks: sailor deserts, opens bar in Nagasaki
    • Will AI replace human translation?
    • Flexible devices and the problem of battery safety
    • Trump says Japan's PM nominated him for Nobel Peace Prize
    • Gunman kills 5 people, wounds 5 police at Illinois business
    • North Koreans pay tribute to Kim's father in freezing cold
    • Koreas to field joint teams in 4 sports at 2020 Tokyo Olympics
    • Let us build peace together
    • Legal battles ahead for Trump's border wall emergency
    • JYP stars get together to promote ITZY debut
    • Rapper San E blasted for 'love for hidden cams'
    • IU thrills students with surprise school visit
    • 'Five Actors' aims to narrow generation gap
    • [Movie Review] 'Svaha,' horrifying mystery thriller about religious exploitation
    • Compensate forced labor

    • Fire in hardware store district

    • We're hiring

    • Listing Woori Financial shares

    • Traditional liquor for 1st full moon

    • Special offer on pork belly

    • Celebrating Korea-Czech relations

    • To-be-built dormitory

    The Right to Protest, Freedom of Expression, and Freedom of Association
    • About Korea Times
    • CEO Message
    • Times History
    • Contents Distribution
    • Media Kit
    • Contact Us
    • Location
    • Privacy Statement
    • Ombudsman
    • Mobile Service
    • PDF Service
    • RSS Service