alt
Posted : 2012-05-04 17:03
Updated : 2012-05-04 17:03

Chinese upset in kimchi cabbage row


By Chung Min-uck

Chinese cabbage has been the name for the main ingredient for the Korean side dish kimchi. But now Koreans are establishing sovereignty over what they eat by having an international naming organization almost decide to call it “kimchi cabbage.”

Of course, there are grounds for the name change with the change in appearance, but Chinese netizens are upset at the adjective indicating the nationality of the vegetable being withdrawn and are showing their displeasure.

As it has been with other cases they have reacted on the basis of strong nationalism, perhaps reflecting their growing global power. In some cases, they are ahead of their government in their eagerness to flex their muscle.

Chinese internet users are showing discontent over the Codex Alimentarius Commission’s decision to adopt the name “kimchi cabbage” as an international standard.

The Codex was created by the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations and World Health Organization in 1963 to develop food standards, guidelines and related texts.

Standards set by the commission serve as international guidelines for foods.

“This incident proves that our government is a big loser,” wrote a Chinese user named Bernieyin in Weibo, a popular Twitter-like microblogging site, Friday. “If we don’t take care of precious things that our ancestors left for us, it means that we are not learning anything from the incident of the Dano holiday.”

The Chinese claim Korea stole Dano, a celebration promoting abundant crops after harvest, as it originated from ancient times in China. It is now a major holiday in Korea.

“Koreans claim they are the founders of kimchi. They try to call cabbage originally from China’s Northeastern region kimchi cabbage,” said a user named MoguHouMianbao.

“Our government should make some kind of move,” said a user named ZiseOuran520.

The cabbage was categorized as “Chinese cabbage” until the 44th session of the meeting of the Codex Committee on Pesticide Residues held in Shanghai last month.

According to Korea Food and Drug Administration (KFDA), the Codex adopted the proposal made by Korean participants to classify specific kinds of Chinese cabbage as Kimchi cabbage since the organization recognized the difference in the shape.

“It is true that the cabbage comes from China. But the shape of Chinese cabbages that are cultivated in Korea has changed,” said Im Moo-hyeong, a researcher at the KDFA who participated in the latest meeting of the codex committee. “The members of the committee admitted that the shape of kimchi cabbage is different as its leaves tend to grow to the center while that of the Chinese cabbage grow outward.”

Im said he refrained from requesting the cabbage be named “Korean cabbage” due to a possible backlash from Chinese members.

The researcher also added that Chinese participants were relatively friendly concerning the name change during a workshop held prior to the meeting.

The name “kimchi cabbage” is waiting to get final approval by the commission’s general assembly next July.

Kimchi, made by soaking cabbages in brine and applying marinade in between the leaves, is the most well-known Korean dish. Many Koreans eat kimchi on a daily basis; and it is well-recognized among foreigners as Korean food.
관련 한글 기사

“김치 캐비지” 채택에 중국 네티즌 분노

그 동안 “중국 배추 (Chinese cabbage)”로 불려 온 한국산 배추가 “김치 배추 (kimchi cabbage)”라는 이름으로 국제식품분류에 등재된 데 대해 중국 네티즌들이 분노하고 있다.

식품의약품안정청은 앞서 지난 달 중국 상하이에서 열린 제44차 국제식품규격위원회(Codex) 농약잔류분과위원회에 제출한 위 내용의 안건이 채택되었다고 밝힌 바 있다.

아이디가 “모구호우미엔바오(蘑菇猴面包)”인 한 중국 네티즌은 4일 마이크로블로그 웨이보(微博)에 “한국인들은 자신들이 김치의 종주국이라고 말하며 중국 동북지역에서 재배되는 배추를 '김치 배추'라고 부르려 한다”며 비판적인 시각을 보였다.

아이디 Bernieyin의 한 네티즌은 “입장을 바꿔 생각하면 이번 일은 우리 정부가 최대 패배자”라며 정부의 무능함을 탓했으며, 아이디가 “즈스어오우란520(紫色偶然520)”인 또 한 명의 중국 네티즌은 “관련 부처가 응당한 행동을 취해야 한다며” 명칭 변경을 저지할 것을 당부했다.

명칭에 대한 최종 결정은 내년 7월 국제식품규격위원회 총회에서 확정될 예정이다.

회의에 참석한 당국자에 따르면 “코리안 배추 (Korean cabbage)”라는 이름으로 신청을 하게 되면 중국과의 불필요한 마찰을 빚을 수 있다는 판단 하에 “김치 배추”라는 이름으로 신청했다고 한다.

또 회의 전 진행 된 워크숍에서 한국 측의 이러한 제안에 대해 중국 당국자들은 생각보다 우호적인 입장을 보였다고 말했다.


  • 1. Man accused of having sex with a mattress
  • 2. Cyclists wreak havoc on highway
  • 3. Divided we are over Sewol
  • 4. Lee Honey shuts down talk of 'rivalry' with co-star
  • 5. Fugitive arrested after posting Ice-Bucket Challenge video on Facebook
  • 6. Smuggling of human-flesh pills on rise
  • 7. Watch: Goliath grouper swallows shark
  • 8. Apartment security guards frequently abused
  • 9. Ministry says compound in Cass beer 'harmless'
  • 10. U.S. envoy's departure triggers concern
Copy editors wanted
Experienced reporters wanted