alt
Posted : 2010-06-24 19:06
Updated : 2010-06-24 19:06

Hyo-ri’s plagiarism scandal snowballs


By Bae Ji-sook
Staff reporter

Sensation over six of singer Lee Hyo-ri's songs, apparently plagiarized by Bahnus, is about to snowball as more singers and industry insiders claim to have been duped by the composer.

Bahnus, the leader of the seven-member composers' group Bahnus Vacuum, faces a string of lawsuits that extend to his management and team members. The looming legal battles are expected to be the largest in K-pop history.

On Wednesday, Chang, the management director of Bahnus Vacuum, said he had found a "statement of regret" written by Bahnus, whose real name is Lee Jae-young, on Lee's computer hard disc. The letter was, surprisingly, not for Lee Hyo-ri but for a relatively unknown singer Lee Hyun, written two years ago.

Lee Hyun, who sang "Jajonshim" (pride) written by Bahnus in 2008, received complaints from another composer Kim just a few days after the song was released. Kim claimed the rhythm, melody and lyrics were identical to his creation.

When Lee Hyun asked Bahnus for an explanation, he promised to drop his name from the credits and pay a refund for the song.

Chang said Bahnus, who introduced himself as "a Yonsei University graduate who had sold numerous songs to foreign artists during his stay in the U.K," lied about other things too.
"He was not a Yonsei University graduate and the contracts he had suggested for potential song sales were also fabricated," he told a local daily.

"Had I seen the letter before, if I had known that Bahnus was a conman, I would never have started the company to support young talented composers," Chang said. The businessman is planning to sue Bahnus for fraud.

The case emerged when Lee Hyo-ri admitted on her website Sunday that six of her songs in the album "H-Logic" were "borrowed" from other singers.

The songs were all credited to Bahnus Vacuum. The songwriter initially told the enraged singer that the demo tape of the songs suffered premature exposure. Lee said she would wrap up all the promotion and will compensate those whose copyrights have been violated.

The K-pop diva's agency Mnet Media said it has contacted the copyright holder of two of the six problematic songs and also plans to sue the songwriter this week for fraud.
If convicted, Lee Jae-young, could be subject to up to three years imprisonment or fined up to 30 million won ($26,000).

Singers' responsibility

Some suggest that it is time singers and their management take more responsibility for plagiarism in show biz.

Over the past several years, those who were "revealed to have been heavily inspired by others," tried to cover up the case by withdrawing the song release and paying the copyright holder and giving credits as "co-writer." Singers Lee Seung-chul, Lee Seung-ki and ironically Lee Hyo-ri, too, had been accused of such in the past and returned with new albums in no time.

However, pop music fans are calling for deeper admonishment. Back in the 1990s, singers who were exposed to have copied other people's creations had to endure criticism and a certain period of time under the media radar to properly express their regret to the public.

In 1995, Lee Sang-min, leader of then-most popular dance group Roo'Ra, attempted suicide after one of the songs in the group's newly released album turned out to be heavily inspired by a Japanese song.

Singer Kim Min-jong, in 1996, one of Korea's most popular singers at the time, announced his retirement after his smash-hit song turned out to have been a copy of another Japanese song. He made a comeback two years after staying "silent and remorseful."

"I think more people are becoming insensitive to plagiarism and its severity. But plagiarism harms the singer and the local entertainment industry. We need a tighter screening system and above all, willingness to root out the illegality," blogger Blackmusel said. "We should also watch over them."



이효리 표절 시비 갈수록 증폭

표절된 것으로 밝혀진 가수 이효리의 6 개 곡을 두고 논란이 지속될 전망이다. 더 많은 가수들과 업계관계자들이 표절작곡가에게 속았다고 주장하기 때문이다.

6 명의 작곡가로 구성된 바누스 바쿰의 리더 바누스는 그의 소속사, 팀 멤버 그리고 이효리로부터 법적대응을 당할 지경에 처해있다. 이는 가요사상 최대 규모가 될 전망이다.

바누스바쿰의 사장 장씨는 바누스의 컴퓨터 하드디스크에서 "반성문"을 찾았다고 수요일 밝혔다. 이 편지는 놀랍게도 이효리가 아닌 무명의 가수 이현에게 이년 전에 쓴 것이었다.

이현은 바누스로부터 2008년 자존심이라는 곡을 받았는데, 동료 작곡가 김씨로부터 출시 직후 항의를 받았다. 노래의 리듬, 음정 그리고 가사까지 자신의 곡이랑 똑같다고 주장한 것이다

  • 1. 'Religious cult tried to kill me,' TV food critic says
  • 2. Death penalty demanded over soldier's death
  • 3. Hatchet-wielding man attacks two NY cops
  • 4. 'Crabzilla' doesn't scare off two curious boys
  • 5. Allies agree to maintain status quo on OPCON
  • 6. Olivia Hussey has half-Korean son
  • 7. Rock icons rally around ailing N.EX.T singer Shin Hae-chul
  • 8. Public outcry over Hitler's face on coffee milk lids
  • 9. Man sentenced for killing thief
  • 10. Dongducheon opposes US troop plan
Copy editors wanted
Experienced reporters wanted