The Korea Times close
National
  • Politics
  • Diplomacy
  • Defense
  • Labor & Environment
  • Law & Crime
  • Health & Welfare
  • Embassy
  • Seoul & Provinces
  • Education
  • Foreign Communities
  • Obituaries
  • Multicultural Youth Award
Biz & Tech
  • Auto
  • IT
  • Game
  • Manufacturing
  • Retail & Food
  • Energy
  • Construction
  • Airlines
Finance
  • Policies
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Banks
  • Non-banks
  • Economic Essay Contest
Opinion
  • Editorial
  • Columns
  • Thoughts of the Times
  • Cartoon
  • Today in History
  • Blogs
  • Tribune Service
  • Blondie & Garfield
  • Letter to the Editor
Lifestyle
  • Arts
  • Books
  • Travel & Cuisine
  • Trend
  • Fashion
  • Around Town
  • Fortune Telling
Entertainment
  • K-pop
  • K-dramas & Shows
  • Movies
  • Music
  • Performances
  • Asia Model Festival
Sports
  • Football
  • Golf
  • Baseball
  • Other Sports
World
  • Asia Pacific
  • Americas
  • Europe & Africa
  • SCMP
Video
  • On the Spot
  • Feature
  • News
Photos
  • Photo News
  • Darkroom
Community
  • The Korea Times
  • search
  • Site Map
  • E-paper
  • Subscribe
  • Register
  • LogIn
search close
  • The Korea Times
  • search
  • Site Map
  • E-paper
  • Subscribe
  • Register
  • LogIn
search close
National
  • Politics
  • Diplomacy
  • Defense
  • Labor & Environment
  • Law & Crime
  • Health & Welfare
  • Embassy
  • Seoul & Provinces
  • Education
  • Foreign Communities
  • Obituaries
  • Multicultural Youth Award
Thu, January 21, 2021 | 16:56
Defense
Ruling causes debate on how to screen conscientious objectors
Posted : 2018-11-02 18:00
Updated : 2018-11-02 19:20
Mail
Print Preview
Font Size Up
Font Size Down

By Lee Suh-yoon

Controversy is brewing over how to verify the "sincerity" of conscientious objectors, after a landmark Supreme Court ruling Thursday recognized religious beliefs as a justifiable reason for refusing mandatory military service.

Chief Justice Kim Myeong-su said in the verdict that the prosecution and the court would assess conscientious objector's claims by looking at "his family, childhood development, school life and other social experiences."

The court said that in a case, the accused would present materials that can prove his conscientious objection and the prosecution and the court will determine the sincerity.

Four justices, who disagreed with the 13-member bench's majority ruling, expressed concerns over the difficulty in distinguishing a person's true beliefs as opposed to someone pretending to have those beliefs.

"Whether one's expressed conscience is true cannot be proven in a criminal court trial," Justice Lee Ki-taik told the courtroom.

Justice Park Sang-ok also echoed Lee's point, saying justifiable reasons for refusing military conscription have to be "consistent and objective, such as a medical condition."

"Subjective circumstances like religion or values are not a justifiable reason for refusing military service," he said.

While most conscientious objectors here are Jehovah's Witness followers, some also doubt how the prosecution or the court can distinguish the sincerity of a person's belief if they do not belong to that specific religion, and refuse military service by claiming their own belief in pacifism.

According to a 2016 survey by Amnesty Korea, around 70 percent of Koreans said they "cannot understand" conscientious objectors. Thursday's ruling unleashed a new onslaught of criticism against them.

At the forefront are conservative groups and politicians, who immediately issued statements citing fears of national security. They claim conscientious objection would become an exploited loophole, leading to a lack of military personnel for the country, still technically at war with North Korea.

"If everyone refuses to serve in the military now, who will protect this country?" Rep. Kim Jin-tae from the opposition Liberty Korea Party (LKP) tweeted Friday.

Rights activists and human rights lawyers say such criticism is groundless, citing examples of other countries such as Norway where recognizing conscientious objection did not lead to an increase in objectors.

The issue of fairness was also tossed around, with social media flooded with comments.

"Is the court saying the people who just suck it up and serve in the military do so because they don't have a conscience?" one user said.

The fairness issue is a sensitive one, especially for men who have already finished their military duty. The reaction is not surprising, considering how mandatory military service exposes young men to human rights abuses in a strict authoritarian hierarchy, leaving a painful imprint.

On an order from the Constitutional Court in June, the government is developing plans for alternative civilian service options and plans to announce these next week.


Emailsylee@koreatimes.co.kr Article ListMore articles by this reporter









 
WooriBank
 
  • Speed skater sues ex-teammate over mental damage following Olympic controversy
  • LG Electronics hints at withdrawing from phone biz
  • 'Learning foreign language is about changing yourself'
  • International students to be included in mandatory health insurance program
  • Academic activist puts kimchi ad in NYT
  • Biracial Korean teacher promotes openness through education
  • Moon replaces foreign minister ahead of Biden inauguration
  • Man gets life sentence for killing girlfriend and her sister
  • Moon names Chung Eui-yong as new foreign minister
  • Ebay to sell Korean online retail platforms
  • K-pop expands from entertainment to activism K-pop expands from entertainment to activism
  • Red Velvet's Irene to make silver screen debut in February Red Velvet's Irene to make silver screen debut in February
  • Actress Park Si-yeon apologizes after getting nabbed for drunk driving Actress Park Si-yeon apologizes after getting nabbed for drunk driving
  • 'It's Okay to Not Be Okay' star Oh Jung-se returns with powerful social drama 'It's Okay to Not Be Okay' star Oh Jung-se returns with powerful social drama
  • Singer John Park in isolation facility after testing positive for COVID-19 Singer John Park in isolation facility after testing positive for COVID-19
DARKROOM
  • Biden takes office as 46th president [PHOTOS]

    Biden takes office as 46th president [PHOTOS]

  • Biden-Harris inauguration is taking shape

    Biden-Harris inauguration is taking shape

  • Second Trump impeachment

    Second Trump impeachment

  • Pro-Trump rioters breach the US Capitol

    Pro-Trump rioters breach the US Capitol

  • Our children deserve better (Part 2)

    Our children deserve better (Part 2)

WooriBank
  • About Korea Times
  • CEO Message
  • Times History
  • Content Sales
  • Media Kit
  • Contact Us
  • Location
  • Privacy Statement
  • Terms of Service
  • Mobile Service
  • RSS Service
  • Ombudsman
  • hankookilbo
  • Dongwha Group
  • Code of Ethics
Copyright